Two reproductions of a human-assessed comparative evaluation of a semantic error detection system

In this paper, we present the results of two re- production studies for the human evaluation originally reported by Dušek and Kasner (2020) in which the authors comparatively evaluated outputs produced by a semantic error detection system for data-to-text generation against ref- erence outputs. In the first reproduction, the original evaluators repeat the evaluation, in a test of the repeatability of the original evaluation. In the second study, two new evaluators carry out the evaluation task, in a test of the reproducibility of the original evaluation under otherwise identical conditions. We describe our approach to reproduction, and present and analyse results, finding different degrees of re- producibility depending on result type, data and labelling task. Our resources are available and open-sourced