Ex Ante Skewness and Expected Stock Returns

We use a sample of option prices, and the method of Bakshi, Kapadia and Madan (2003), to estimate the ex ante higher moments of the underlying individual securities’ risk-neutral returns distribution. We find that individual securities’ volatility, skewness and kurtosis are strongly related to subsequent returns. Specifically, we find a negative relation between volatility and returns in the cross-section. We also find a significant relation between skewness and returns, with more negatively (positively) skewed returns associated with subsequent higher (lower) returns, while kurtosis is positively related to subsequent returns. To analyze the extent to which these returns relations represent compensation for risk, we use data on index options and the underlying index to estimate the stochastic discount factor over the 1996-2005 sample period, and allow the stochastic discount factor to include higher moments. We find evidence that, even after controlling for differences in co-moments, individual securities’ skewness matters. However, when we combine information in the risk-neutral distribution and the stochastic discount factor to estimate the implied physical distribution of industry returns, we find little evidence that the distribution of technology stocks was positively skewed during the bubble period–in fact, these stocks have the lowest skew, and the highest estimated Sharpe ratio, of all stocks in our sample