The narrative of the death of the Prophet Muhammad is not just one. History in Sunni, He died in the lap of Aisha RA. While in the Shi'i narration, he died in the lap of Ali bin Abi Talib. These two narrations are also widespread in two conflicting Madrasas, Kufa (Shi'i) and Basra (nashibi). Thus, both camps can objectively narrate these two Hadiths. In this study, the author highlights the historical pattern of the narration of these two contradicting Hadiths to conclude the role of fanaticism in the spread of religious understanding, especially in the space of these hadiths. To solve the problem in question, the author uses content analysis with the al-ruwāt date approach. Due to the broad scope of discussion, in this paper, the author li...