Future of the brand management structure in FMCG: A two-dimensional perspective

The brand management structure has been in use in the fast moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector for quite some time. Researchers have tracked the historical development of organising for managing manufacturer brands covering the period dating back to the 1870s. Currently, there is debate on what the future holds for the brand management structure given changes that are taking place in the marketing environment, and the debate remains unresolved. This study seeks to explore the question of how FMCG marketing practitioners perceive the future of the brand management structure. While the key players in FMCG include manufacturers and retailers, a review of the literature has shown that previous research has largely neglected the retailer dimension, which is a relevant dimension in the FMCG equation. The dimension becomes even more important in the wake of extant literature's emphasis on the growing power of distribution channels. This research is a two-dimensional perspective that explores the views of manufacturers on the one hand and retail chain stores on the other. Based on the literature, four research questions are developed on the current state of organising for managing manufacturer brands, the management of house brands, perceptions on a shift in the locus of power from manufacturers to retailers, and perceptions on the future of the brand management structure. The research questions are investigated using the case study methodology, focusing on FMCG firms in the New Zealand dairy sector on the manufacturer side and a chain store on the retailer side. Data collection is done using in-depth interviews. The data are subjected to qualitative forms of analysis. While there are other sub-factors investigated on each research question, the main finding from both dimensions is that the brand management structure is not outdated; it is still useful and works well for some companies, and in certain cases, the structure is used alongside category management. Abandoning the brand management structure would have a negative impact on innovation. The findings largely support previous research that concluded that the brand management structure will not disappear from the scene. Theoretically, this study has added a fresh and relevant dimension to the debate. The new dimension has produced results that are largely consistent with the manufacturer side of the FMCG sector and with previous research. The findings contribute to the body of knowledge on the future of the brand management structure and have managerial implications as well. Directions for future research are also identified.UnpublishedAaker, D. (1996), Managing Brand Equity: Capltalising on the Value of the Brand Name, New York, NY: The Free Press. Achrol, R. S. (1991), "Evolution of the marketing organisation: New forms for turbulent environments", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 55, October, pp. 77-93. Adams, G. & White, J. (1994), "Dissertation research in public administration and cognate fields: An assessment of methods and quality", Vol. 54 No. 6, pp. 565-576. Advertising Works (2003), "The future of private brands in New Zealand", Coriolis Research, September, p. 4. Ailawadi, K. L. (2001), "The retail power performance conundrum: What have we learned?", Journal of Retailing,V 77 Iss. 3, pp. 299-318. Ames, C. B. (1963), "Payoff from product management", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 41, November-December, pp. 141-152. Anderson, P. F. (1982), "Marketing, strategic planning, and the theory of the firm", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 46, Spring, pp. 15-26. Anonymous (2003), "How retailer power changes marketing", Advertising Age (Midwest Region Edition), Chicago, Jul. 21, Vol. 74 Iss. 29, p. 16. Baker, M. J. (1998), "Marketing of the future", Australasian Marketing Journal, Vol. 6 No. l, pp. 5-11. Baker, M. J. (2000), "Editorial", Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 16, pp. l-I0. Bedeian, A. G. & Zammuto, R. F. (1991), Organisations: Theory and Design, Orlando, Florida, The Dryden Press. Bell, J. D. & Duder, J. N. (1998), "The battle for shelf space in New Zealand supermarkets; Do supermarkets favour their own brands with extra and better positioned facings?", Proceedings of the ANZMAC Conference, University of Otago, Dunedin, pp. 170-181. Berthon, P., Hulbert, J. M. & Pitt, L. F. (1997), "Brands, brand managers and the management of brands: Where to next?", MSI Report No. 97-122, Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute. Blattberg, R. C. & Deighton, J. (1991), "Interactive marketing: Exploiting the age of addressability", Sloan Management Review, Fall, pp. 5-14. Bridgeman, D. (2002), "Supermarket war takes ugly turn as price survey pulled", The National Business Review, December 13, p. 57. Buell, V. P. (1975), "The changing role of the product manager in consumer goods companies", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 39 No. 3, pp. 3-11. Bull, J. (1968), "The product management system: Plague or panacea", Business Quarterly, Spring. Bulmer, S. (1998), "FMCG; Driving on the electronic highway or on a side road? A study of the importance of fast moving consumer goods of electronic commerce relative to traditional promotional mix activity", Proceedings of the ANZMAC Conference, University of Otago, Dunedin, pp. 255-262. Byett, A. (2003), "The little country that could", Chartered Accountants Journal of New Zealand, May 1, vol. 82 Iss. 4, p. 47. Carson, D. (1968), "Marketing organisation in British manufacturing firms", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 32, April, pp. 34-39. Carson, D. Gilmore, A., Perry, C. & Gronhaug, K (2001), Qualitative Marketing Research, Sage, London. Cespedes, F. V. (1995), Concurrent marketing: Integrating Product, Sales and Service, Boston, Harvard Business School Press. Chaffey, H. (2004), "Marketing; still the poor cousin in retail – or the new frontier for the truly talented?", Grocers' Review, March. Clark, B. (1995), "World's best practices: Pioneers of the new marketing paradigm", Marketing, Australia, pp. 34-39. Clewett, R. & Stasch, S. (1975), "Shifting role of the product manager", Harvard Business Revlew, May-June, pp. 143-154. Converse, J. & Schuman, H. (1974), Conversations at Random: Survey Research as Interviewers See It, New York, Wiley. Corbett, J. (2002), "Private labels – where to from here?", Grocers' Review, October, pp. 40-41. Coriolis Research (2002), "Responding to private label in New Zealand", Coriolis Research, February, p. 1-37. Dawes, P. & Petterson, P. (1988), "The performance of industrial and consumer product managers", Industrlal Marketing Management, January, pp. 73-84. Day, G. (1997), "Aligning the organisation to the market", in Lehmann, D. R. & Jocz, K. E. (Eds), Reflections on the Futures of Marketing, Cambridge, MA, Marketing Science Institute, pp. 67-93. de Chernatony, L. (1996), "2001 – The brand management odyssey", Journal of General Management, Vol. 21 No. 4, Summer, pp. 15-30. Deshpande, R. (1983), "Paradigms Lost: On theory and method in research in marketing", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 47 No. 4, pp. 101-110. Deshpande, R. & Webster, F. E. (Jr.) (1989), "Organisation culture and marketing: Defining the research agenda", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 53, January, pp. 3-15. Dey, I. (1993), Qualitative Data Analysis, London, Routledge. de Weerd-Nederhof, P. C. (2001), "Qualitative case study research: The case of a PhD research project on organising and managing new product development systems", Management Decision, Vol. 39 No. 7, pp. 513-538. Dick, B. (1990), Convergent Interviewing, Brisbane, Interchange. Donaldson, R. H. (2002), "Outside – in Marketing", Marketing, June, pp. 41-42. Doyle, P. (1993), "Building successful brands: The strategic options", The Journal of Consumer Marketing, Vol. 7 No. 2, pp. 5-20. (1995), "Marketing in the new millennium", European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 29 No.13, pp. 23-41. Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989), "Building theories from case study research", Academy of Management Review, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 532-550. Eldridge, C. E. (1966), The Management of the Marketing Function, New York: Association of National Advertisers. Emory, C. W. & Cooper, D. R. (1991), Business Research Methods, 4th ed., Irwin, Boston, MA. Firestone, W. A. (1993), "Alternative arguments for generalising from data as applied to qualitative research", Education Researcher, Vol. 22 No. 4, pp. 16-23. FitzRoy, P. T. (1998), "The future of marketing – Some personal observations", Australasian Marketing Journal, Vol. 6 No. l, pp. 13-18. Fontana, A. & Frey, J. (1994), "Interviewing: The Art of Science", in Denzin, N. K. & Lincoln, Y. S. (Eds), Handbook of Qualltative Research, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage. Franzoni, L. (1991), "Product managers: Finding the right fit", Bank Marketing, May, pp. 28-31. Gautier, A. (2003), "2002 Mega brands", New Zealand Marketing Magazine, April, pp. 24-29. George, D. (2001), "Technology taking retail back to its roots", Grocers' Review, July, p. 52. George, M., Freeling, M. & Court, D. (1994), "Reinventing the marketing organisation", Mckinsey Quarterly, No. 4, pp. 43-62. Ghauri, P. N., Gronhaug, K. & Kristianslund, I. (1995), Research Methods in Business Studies: A Practical Guide, London, Prentice-Hall. Gill, J. & Johnson, P. (1991), Research Methods for Managers, London, Paul Chaplin. Gilmore, A. & Carson, D. (1996), "Integrative qualitative researching: A services context", Marketing Intelligence & Planning, Vol. 14 No. 6, pp. 21-26. Goold, M. & Campbell, A. (2002), "Do you have a well-designed organisation?", Harvard Business Review, Vol 80 Iss. 3, pp. 117-124. Gorchels, L. (1995), "Traditional product management evolves", Marketing News, January, p. 4. Gray, A. (2003), "Editorial big picture thinking", New Zealand Buslness, May, p. 3. Greyser, S. A. (1998), "Janus and marketing: The past, present, and prospective future of marketing", in Lehmann, D. R. & Jocz K. E. (Eds), Reflections on the Futures of Marketing, Cambridge, MA, Marketing Science Institute, pp. 3-14. Grocers' Review (2003a), "Progressive lays down the gauntlet", Grocers' Review, November, p. 6. Grocers' Review (2003b), "Manufacturer gets barred from Foodstuffs", Grocers' Review, June, P. 8. Grohaug, K. & Olson, 0. (1999), "Action research and knowledge creation: Merits and challenges", Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, Vol. 2 No. 1, pp. 6-14. Guba, E. G. & Lincoln, Y. S. (2000), "Competing paradigms in qualitative research", in Denzin, N. K. & Lincoln, Y. S. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Newbury Park, CA, Sage. Hamel, G. & Pralahad, C. K. (1994), "Competing for the future", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 72 Iss. 4, pp. 122-128. Hankinson, P. & Cowking, P. (1997), "Branding in practice: The profile and role of brand managers in the UK", Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 19, pp. 76-81. Hedges, A. (1985), "Group interviewing", in Walker, R. (Eds), Applied Qualitative Research, Gower, Aldershot. Homburg, C., Workman, J. P.(Jr.) & Jensen, O. (2000), "Fundamental changes in marketing organisation: The movement toward a customer-focused organisational structure", Journal of the Academy of Marketlng Science, Vol. 28 Iss. 4, pp. 459-478. Hornsby, A. S. (1998), Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary of Current English, 5th ed., Oxford, Oxford University Press. Hulbert, J. M. & Pitt, L. (1995), "Exit left centre stage? The future of functional marketing", European Management Journal, Vol. 14 No. 1, pp. 47-60. Hunt, S. (1991), Modern Marketing Theory, Cincinnati, Ohio, South Western Publishing. Jacobs, R. H. (1961), "The effective use of the product manager", The Marketing Job, New York: American Management Association. Katsanis, L. P. & Pitta, D. A. (1995), "Punctuated equilibrium and the evolution of the product manager", Journal of Product and Brand Management, Vol. 4 No. 3, pp. 49-60. Keith, R. J. (1960), "The marketing revolution", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 24, January, pp. 35-38. Kiel, G. (1998), "Research and education: Marketing in the future", Australasian Marketing Journal, Vol. 6 No. 1, pp. 23-29. Kleizen, H., Beaton, G. and Abratt, R. (1985), "Pharmaceutical Product Management in the 1990s: Will there be any changes?", European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 19, pp. 76-81. Kotler, P. (2000), Marketing Management, 10th ed., New Jersey, Prentice-Hall, Inc. Krief, B. (1975), Marketing Effectlveness through Organisational Structure, New York and Toronto, John Wiley and Sons, Inc. Lawrence, K. (1999), "Marketing under siege", in Marketing, February, pp. 24-29. Lehmann, D. R. (1998), "Some thoughts on the futures of marketing", in Lehmann, D. R. & Jocz, K. E. (Eds), Reflections on the Futures of Marketing, Cambridge, MA, Marketing Science Institute, pp. 121-135. Lehmann, D. R. & Jocz, K. E. (1998), "Editor's Note", in Lehmann, D. R. & Jocz K. E. (Eds), Reflections on the Futures of Marketing, Cambridge, MA, Marketing Science Institute, pp. v-vi Le Pla, R. (2002), "Branding", New Zealand Marketing Magazine, September, pp. 9-13. Lief, A. (1958), "It Flows", The Story of Proctor & Gamble, New York: Rinehart & Company. Lief, A. (1963), The Moon and Stars, Cincinnati, OH: The Proctor & Gamble Company. Lindblom, A. (2001), "Institutionalisation of category management in the manufacturer-retailer relationships", Proceedings of the ANZMAC Conference, Massey University, Palmerston North. Low, G. S. & Fullerton, R. A. (1994), "Brands, brand management and the brand manager system: A critical-historical evaluation", Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 31, pp. I73-190. Luck, D. & Nowac, Th. (1965), "Product management – Vision unfulfilled", Harvard Business Review, May-June, pp. 143-154. Lysonski, S. (1985), "A boundary theory investigation of the product manager's role", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 49 No. 1, pp. 26-40. Lysonski, S.& Durvasula, S. (I990), "Effects of moderating variables on product managers' behaviour: A re-examination", Psychological Reports, Vol. 67, pp. 687-690. Mavondo, F. T. & Hardley, F. (2000), "The marketing implications of competition, cooperation", Proceedings of the ANZMAC Conference, Griffith University, Gold Coast, pp. 1513-1519. McManus, G. (1995), "Biting into the breakfast market", New Zealand Marketing Magazine, Vol. 14 No. 8, pp. 35-37. Meredith, B. H. (2002), "The big secret", NZ Business, July, Vol. 16, Iss. 6, p. 47. Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A. M. (1994), Qualitative Data Analysis –An Expanded Sourcebook, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage. Miller, C. (1993), Upbeat outlook for US brands", Marketing News, Vol. 8 No. 11, pp. l-8. Moore, P. (2003), "11 ways to get noticed", New Zealand Marketing Magazine, March, pp. 32-35. Morein, J. A. (1975), "Shift from brand to product line marketing", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 53, September – October, pp. 56-64. Morris, T. & Wood, S. (1991), "Testing the survey method: Continuity and change in British industrial relations", Work Employment and Society, Vol. 5 No. 2, pp. 259-282. Murphy, W. H. & Gorchels, L. (1996), "How to improve product management effectiveness", Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 25, pp. 47-58. Neuman, W. L. (1994), Social Research Methods, Allyn and Bacon, Boston. New Zealand Trade and Enterpise (2003, October), New Zealand Dairy Industry, Internet WWW page, at URL: http:www.marketnewzealand.com/MNZ/MarketIntelligence/sectors.aspx? sectionID=13486&content=8026 (Accessed: 2004, December 10). Nola, C. (2002), "Collaborate or die", Grocers' Review, June, pp. 34-35. O'brien, P. & Campbell, K. (2002), "Amsterdam's private label exhibition", Grocers' Revlew, July, pp. 56-57. Ouchi, W. G. & Van de Ven, A. H. (1980), "Antitrust and organisation theory", in Williamson, 0. (Eds), Antitrust Law and Economics, Houston, TX, Dame Publication Inc. Panigyrakis, G. & Glynn, L. (1992), "Women consumer product managers in France", in Baker, M. J. (Eds), Marketing Perspectives, Vol. 2, Addison Wesley, London, UK. Panigyrakis, G.& Veloutsou, C. (1999a), "Brand manager interfaces in different consumer goods industries", Journal of Product and Brand Management, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp. 19-37. Panigyrakis, G.& Veloutsou, C. (1999b), "Brand manager relations with industrial service providers in pharmaceutical and other companies", Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, Vol. 14 No. 3, pp. 229-245. Panigyrakis, G.& Veloutsou, C. A. (2000), "Problems and future of the brand management structure in the fast moving consumer goods industry: The viewpoint of brand managers in Greece", Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 16, pp. 165- 184. Parkhe, A. (1993), "Messy research, methodological predispositions and theory development in international joint ventures", Academy of Management Review, Vol. 18 No. 2, pp. 227-268. Patton, M. Q. (1992), Qualitatlve Evaluation and Research Methods, Sage, Newbury Park. Perry, C. (1998a), "Processes of case study methodology for postgraduate research in marketing", European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 32 No. 9/10, pp. 785-802. Perry, C. (1998b), "A structured approach for presenting theses", Australasian Marketing Journal, Vol. 6 No. l, pp. 63-85. Perry, C., Riege, A. & Brown. L, (1999), "Realism's role amongst scientific paradigms in marketing research, Irlsh Marketing Review, Vol. 12 No. 2, pp. 16-23. Phillips, E. M. & Pugh, D. S. (2000), How to Get a PhD, 3 rd ed., Buckingham, Philadelphia, Open University Press. Printers' Ink (1960), "Why modern marketing needs the product manager", Vol. 273, October 14, pp. 25-30. Ragin, C. G. & Becker, H. S. (1992), What is a Case? Exploring the Foundations of Social Enquiry, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Richards, A. (1994), "What is holding today's brand manager?", Marketing, February 3, pp. 16- 17. Robbins, S. P. & Barnwell, N. (1994), Organisation Theory in Australia, 2nd Sydney, Prentice Hall. Robson, C. (1993), Real World Research, Oxford, Blackwell. Rogers, E. M. (1962), Diffusion of Innovations, New York, The Free Press of Glencoe. Romanelli, E. & Tushman, M. L. (1994), "Organisational transformation as punctuated equilibrium: An empirical test", Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 37 No.l, pp. 1141- 1166. Romano, C. (1989), "Research strategies for small business: A case study", International Small Business Journal, Vol. 7 No. 4, pp. 35-43. Ruekert, R. W., Walker, O. C. (Jr) & Roering, K. J. (1985), "The organisation of marketing activities: A contingency theory of structure and performance", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 49, Winter, pp. 13-25. Salamon, L. A. (1981), "The goals of reorganisation: A framework for analysis", Administration and Society, Vol. 12, pp. 471-500. Sales Management (1967), "Has the product manager failed? Or the folly imitation",Vol. 98, January 1, pp. 27-30, 65-66. Saunders, M., Lewis, P. & Thornhill, A. (1997), Research Methods for Business Students, London, Pitman Publishing. Schultz, L. (2003), "Supermarket design – What's in store", Grocers' Review, November, pp. 24-25. Schutte, T. F. (1969), "The semantics of branding", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33, April, pp. 5-11. Shocker, A. D., Srivastava, R. K. & Ruekert, R. W. (1994), "Challenges and opportunities facing brand management: An introduction to the special issue", Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 31 No. 2, pp. 149-158. Starbuck, W. H. & Nysrom, P. C. (1981), "Why the world needs organisational design", Journal of General Management, Vol. 6 Iss. 3, pp. 3-17. Stevenson, B. (1989), "Product management in corporate banking", International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 7, pp. 17-21. Stringleman, H. (2001), "Finally Fonterra", Marketing Magazine, October, pp. 16-17. Strydom, J. W., Cant, M. C., & Jooste, C. J. (2000), Marketing Management, 4th ed., Kewyn, Juta and Co. Ltd. Trochim, W. M. (2000, August 02), The Research Methods Knowledge Base, 2 nd ed., Internet WWW page, at URL:http://trochim.human.cornell.edu/lcb/index.htm (Accessed: 2003, March 24). Tushman, M. and Scanlan, T. (1981), "Characteristics of external orientations of boundary spanning individuals", Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 24, pp. 83-98. Uncles, M. (2003), "The future of marketing as a study with substance", ANZMAC Conference, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Opening Plenary Session. Vecchio, R. P., Hearn, G. & Southey, G. (1988), Organlsational Behaviour: Life at Work in Australia, Sydney, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. Webster, F. E. (Jr.) (1981), "Top management's concerns about marketing issues of the 1980s", Journal of Marketlng, Vol, 45, Summer, pp. 9-16. Webster, F. E. (Jr.) (1992), "The changing role of marketing in the corporation", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 56, October, pp. l-17. Webster, F. E. (Jr.) (1997), "The future role of marketing in the organisation", in Lehmann D. R. and Jocz K. E. (Eds), Reflections on the Futures of Marketing, Cambridge: MA, Marketing Science Institute, pp. 39-66. Weinstein, S. (1994), "A case for national brands", Progressive Grocer, Vol. 73 No. 4, pp. 109- 110. Wichman, W. (1989), "Product management: Still a way to go?", Bank Marketing, Vol. 21, pp. 44-46. Wood, V. R. & Tandon, S. (1994), "Key components in product management success (and failure): A model of product managers' job performance and job satisfaction in the turbulent 1990s and beyond", The Journal of Product and Brand Management, Vol. 3 No. l, pp. I9-34. Yarwood, V. (1994), "On the brand wagon: The fight for space on supermarket shelves", Management, Auckland, July, pp. 44-50. Yin, R. K. (2003), Case Study Research – Design and Methods, Applied Social Research Methods Series, Vol. 5, 3rd ed., Thousand Oaks, California, Sage Publications. Young, C. (1995), "Winning brand strategies", New Zealand Marketing Management, May, pp. 31-34. Zenor, M. J. (1994),