Foreign sourcing behavior of New Zealand retail SMEs

Foreign sourcing is a tool used by many organisations to improve competitive advantage. This study builds upon foreign sourcing theory by examining the foreign sourcing behaviour of small to medium retail enterprises (SMEs). To provide a holistic understanding of foreign sourcing behaviour, six constructs were investigated; these include motivations, benefits, barriers, supply chain management, purchasing strategy and mode selection. This study also identifies significant relationships between constructs' previously not identified in the literature. This research enquiry uses an inductive theory-building approach. This approach overcomes the confines of current theory which include; the limited context within which past studies have been conducted (predominately multinational manufacturers), the treatment of constructs in isolation, and, the dominant use of deductive theory-building research approaches. Seventeen retailers participated in this study across three retail sectors, jewellery, gift/homeware and delicatessens. Information was gathered Using a combination of semi-structured interviews and shop observations. Findings indicate that the foreign sourcing motivations and benefits of retail SMEs are largely consistent with those of manufacturing multinational enterprises (MNEs). Foreign sourcing barriers, however, differ based on both organisational size and industry. Supply chain management, purchasing strategy and made selection are also dependent on organisational size and industry, as well as the individual retailer's desired level of commitment and risk. The most notable relationship between the six foreign sourcing constructs is the influence that the choice of sourcing mode has on both foreign sourcing benefits and barriers. Furthermore, testament to the inductive research design, five factors also emerged that had previously not been identified in the literature. These include the motivator of gap in the market, the two benefits of point of difference and supplier knowledge, and the barriers of lack of information and education of customers. The findings of this study make a contribution to foreign sourcing theory. They also provide guidance for retail SMEs when selecting their foreign sourcing mode, and suggest innovation as a means for New Zealand manufacturers to improve their competitiveness against foreign imports.UnpublishedAbratt, R . (1986), "Industrial Buying in High-Tech Markets", Industrial Marketing Management, 15(4). Anmmer- D (1974), Materials Management, Irwin Inc ., Homewood, IL. Ahratt .. 'R. (1986), "Industrial Buying In High-Tech Markets", Industrial Marketing Management, 15(4). Ailawadi, K . (2002), "The Retail Power-Performance Conundrum : What Have We learned?" Journal of Retailing, 7(3) Alguire, M ., Fraer, C . & Metcalf, L. (1994), "An Examination of the Determinants of Global Sourcing", The Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, 9(2) . Ammer. D. (1974)- Materials Management, Invin Inc ., Homewood, IL . Anderson, B. (2003), "Global Channel Strategies : What's Right for You`?" International Trade Specialist, US & Foreign Commercial Service : the Cursor : Official .Publication of the Software Association, Oregon, USA. Babble, F. (1998), The Practice of Social Research, Wadsworth, Auflage, Belmont, CA. Baily, P . & Farmer, D . (1982), Materials Management Handbook, Gower, Aldershot, England . Baily, P . (1987), Purchasing and Supply .Management, Chapman & Hall, London . Becker, H ., Gordon, A. & Lebailly, R. (1984), "Field Work with the Computer : Criteria for Assessing Systems", Qualitative Sociology, 7(1-2) . Berg, B . (1989), Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences, Allyn and Bacon. Bork. R., & Rossi, P . (1990), Thinking About Evaluation, Newbury Park; Sage Publications, California, LSSA, Biederzlian, D . (1999),''Foreign Customs Clamp Down" Traffic World, 15(20) . Birou, L. . Fawcett & Stanley, E. (1993), "International Purchasing : Benefits, Requirements, and Challenges", International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, 2.9(2) Bloom, P . & Perry. V . (2001), Retailer Pewer and Supplier Welfare Journal ofRetailing, 77() . : the Case of Wal-Mart?" Bourlakis, M. & Bourlakis, C . (2001), "Deliberate and Emergent Logistics Strategies in Food Retailing : A Case Study of the Greek Multiple Food Retail Sector", Supply Chain Management, 6(3/4). Bowersox, D. & Daugherty, P . (1992), "Logistics Leadership - Logistics Organizations of the Future", Logistics Information Management, 5(12). Bradley, P ., Gooley, T. & Cooke, J . (1998), "New Restrictions Target Import Packaging from China" . Logistics Management and Distribution Report, December, Radnor. Braglia, M . & Petroni, A . (2000), "A Quality Assurance-Oriented Methodology for Handling Trade-Offs in Supplier Selection", International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 30(2) . Burt, S. (1989), "Trends and Management Issues In European Retailing" International Journal of Retailing, 4(4) . Carmichael, M . (1999), "Delicatessen & Fine Foods", Grocer, October. Car, A . & Pearson, J . (2002), "The Impact of Purchasing and Supplier Involvement on Strategic Purchasing and Its Impact on Firm's Performance", international Journal of Operations & Production Management, 22(9/10) . Carter, C . (1982), "For Retailers, It's Time to Beat Tomorrow", Chain Store Age Executive, 58(1). Catterall, M . (1996). "Using Computer Programs to Code Qualitative Data", Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 4(14). Cespedes, F . (1988), "Control vs . Resources in Channel Design : Distribution Differences in One Industry", Industrial Marketing Management, 17(2). Chao, C ., Scheuing, E., Duhas, K. & Mummalaneni, V. (1993), "An Assessment of Supplier Selection : Chinese Purchasing Managers' Criteria and Their Implications for Western Marketers", International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 23(8) . Chawla, S., Derakhshan, F . & Smith., M. (1995), "A Field Investigation of Country of Origin Affects On Consumer Product Evaluations", International Journal of Management, Cho, ,J . & Kang, J . (2001), "Benefits and Challenges of Global Sourcing: Perceptions of US Apparel Retail Firms", International Marketing Review, 18(5) . Choi . S . (1991), "Price Competition in A Channel Structure with A Common Retailer" .. Marketing Science, 10(4). Churchill, G . (1995), Marketing Research : Methodological Foundations 6th Edition, the Dryden Press . Collins, A. & Burt, S . (2003), Market Sanctions, Monitoring and Vertical Coordination within Retailer-Manufacturer Relationships: the Case of -Retail Brand Suppliers . 37(5/6) . Conrad, P . & Shulamit, R . (1984) . "Computers and Qualitative Data", Qualitative Sociology, 7.(1,2) Corey, R. (1978), Procurement Management : Strategy, Organization and Decision Making= CBIP.ublishing, Boston, MA Cotterill. R. (1986), "Market Power In the Retail Food Industry: Evidence From Vermont", the Review of Economics and Statistics, 68 . Council o f Logistics Management (CLM) (1999) . Membership Roster, Oak B rook . IL. Creswell, J . (1994), Research Design : Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches 2nd Edition, Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications, California, USA . Cruz, C. (1997), "Global Economy Pushes Purchasing Offshore”. Purchasing, April 17. Czinkota M . & Ronkainen, 1 . (1993), -International Marketing, the Dryden Press, New York . Dalrymple . J . (2004), "Performance Measurement for SME Growth - A Business Profile Benchmarking Approach", Centre for Management Quality Research. Danielsson. M. & Stolt, T . (2003), How Medium, Sized Enterprises Price Products In international Industrial Markets . Lulea University of Technology . Davis, H ., Eppen, G. & Mattson, L. (t974), "Critical Factors in Worldwide Purchasing", Harvard Business Review, November-December, 52 . Coleman; J. (1981), Longitudinal Data Analysis, Basic Books, New York . Dedona, F. (1986), "Remarks On the Impact of the Strong US Dollar On Corporate Off-Shore Procurement Strategy", Speech Given At the CEO Winterim Seminar,American Graduate School of International Management, Den„ S. & Wortzel, L . (1995), "Importer Purchase Behavior : Guidelines for Asian Exporters". Journal of Business Research, Jan, 32(1). Denzin. N. & Lincoln, Y . (1994), The Art and Politics of Interpretation Thousand Oakes. Sage Publications, California, : Handbook of Qualitative Research U, SA . Denzin, N. & Lincoln, Y . (1998), Entering the Field of Qualitative Research : the Landscape of Qualitative Research, Thousand Island, Sage Publications, California Deshpande, R . (1983) .. "Paradigms Lost on Theory and Method in Research in Marketing", Journal of Marketing, 4(3). Dickson, P . (1997), Marketing Management, 2nd Edition . Dryden Press, Florida ; USA . Dowst (1987), "International Buying - the Facts and Foolishness", Purchasing, June (5) 53 . Eisenhardt, K . (1989), "Building Theories from Case Study Research", Academy of Management Review •, 14(4). El-Ansary, A. & Robicheaux, R. (1974), "A Theory of Channel Control Revisited", Journal of Marketing, January, 38 . Emrnelhainz, L., Emrnelhainz, M. & Stock, J. (1991), "Logistics Implications of Retail Stockouts", Journal of Business Logistics, 12(2) . Engel, C . &Rogers. J. (2001), "Deviations from Purchasing P over Parity : Causes and Welfare Costs", Journal of International Economics, October. Fabbe-Costes, N . & Colin, J . (1999), Formulating Logistics Strategy. Logistics and Distribution Planning, 3rd Ed., Kogan Page; London. Fagan, M. (1991), "A Guide to Global Sourcing", Journal of Business Strategy, Boston: ;12(2) . Fayerweather, J. (1969), International Business Management : Conceptual Framework, Mcgraw Hill, New 'York. Foddy, W. (199 z), Constructing Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires: Theory and Practice in Social Research, University Pres, Cambridge . Fontana, A., & Frey, J . (1994), Interviewing, the Art of Science; Handbook of Qualitative Research, Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications, California, USA . Fraer, C ., Metcalf, L . & Alguire, M . (1992), "Offshore Sourcing: Its Nature and Scope", International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, 28(3) . Fraering, M . & Prasad, S . (1999), "International Sourcing and Logistics : An Integrated Model", Logistics and Information Management, 12(6) . Frazier, G., Spekman, R . & O'Neal, C. (1988), "Just-In-Time Exchange Relationships In Industrial Markets", Journal of Marketing, 52 . Garten, J . (1998), "Cultural Imperialism Is No Joke", Business Week, November. Gephart, R . (1999) "Paradigms and Research Methods", Academy of Management Methods Forum, Summer (1). - Research Geylani, T . (203), The Impact of Retailers' Asymetric Power On Chanel Relations . Available from : Http ://www.Gsm.Uci .Ed/Script/Collooquia/Colloquiaarchive .Asp?'Academicarea=Marketing&Useimage=Marketingheader [Accessed 12 September 2003]. Ghodsypour, S . & O'Brien C . (1998), "A Decision Support System for Supplier Selection Using An Integrated Analytic Hierarchy Process and Linear Programming", Intern Journal of Production Economics, September . Ghymn, K., Liesch. P . & Mattson, 3. (1999), "Australian Import Managers' Purchasing Decision Behaviour: An Empirical Study" International Marketing Review, 16(3) . Gopalkrishnan, I. (1996), "Strategic Decision Making in industrial Procurement : Implications for Buying Decision Approaches and Buyer-Seller Relationships" . The Journal of Business & industrial Marketing, 11(314) • Greene, A . (200 ), "Direct Procurement Comes Into its Own"; M.51, 19(2) . Guba. E . & Lincoln, Y . (1.998), Competing .Paradigms in Qualitative Research : the Landscape of Qualitative Research, Thousand Oaks, S age Publications, California, USA. Gubrium, J . & Holstein, J . (2002) . Handbook of Interview Research : Context method, Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications, California, USA . Gundlach, G . & Murphy, P. (1993), "Ethical & Legal Foundations of Relational Marketing Exchanges", Journal of Marketing, 57(4) . Guthrie. J . ( 14996), "Predicting Future Trends in the Structure o f Retailing in New Zealand: A Qualitative Approach ", PhD . Thesis, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand. Haas, R . (1976), "Economics of the Buy-Sell Agreement", Life Association News, January, 71(1) . Hakansson, H. & Wootz, B . (1975), "Supplier Selection in An International Environment - An Experimental Study", Journal of Marketing Research, February, 12 . Harrison, T . (2401)_ "Global Supply Chain Design", Information Systems Frontiers, Dec. 3(4). Hart, & Saunders, C . (1997), "Power and Trust : Critical Factors In the Adoption and Use of Electronic Data Interchange", Organization Science, 8(1). Hayes, R. & Pisano, G . (1994), "Beyond World-Class: the New Manufacturing Strategy", Harvard Business Review, 72(1) . Haynes, P . & Cappel, S . (1992), "Competitive Strategies and Business Performance within the Retailing Industry" Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 20(5) . Hefler, D . (1981), "Global Sourcing: 0ffshore Investment Strategy for the 1980s", The Journal of Business Strategy, 2(l) . Heli, K., Luostarinen . R. & Welch, L. (1.996), "Internationalisation of SMEs : Inward-Outward Paterns of Government Policy” Management International Review 36(4). Herbig, P . & O'Hara, I3. (1995), "Broadening Horizons: the Practice of Global Relationships In Procurement", Management Decision, 33(9) . Hill, J . & Wright, L . (2001), "A Qualitative Research Agenda for Small to Medium Sized Enterprises", Marketing Intelligence and Planning; 19(6), Hogan, J. & Armstrong, G . (2001), "Toward A Resource-Based Theory of Business Exchange Relationships: the Role of Relational Asset Value", Journal of Business to Business Marketing, 8 Humphreys, K. & McIvor, R. (1998), "Procurement", Logistics Information Management, 11(1). Humphreys, P ., Mak, K. & Yeung, C . (1998), "A .rust-In-Time Evaluation Strategy for International Procurement", Supply Chain Management, 3(4) . Hyde, K. (2000), "Recognising Deductive Processes in Qualitative Research", Qualitative Market Research: An International .Journal, 3 (2). Imbernlan, W . (2001), "Eliminating the Cost of Poor Quality", FDM, Des Plaines : 7 3)(12 1), Ishikawa, K . (1990), Introduction to Quality Control, 3A Corporation, .)use Pres, Tokyo. Jarratt, D . (1996), "A Comparison of Two Alternative Interviewing Techniques Used within An Integrated Research Design : A Case Study in Outshopping Using :Semi-structured and non directed Interviewing Techniques", Jeannet, Y . & Hennessey, H . (1995), Global Marketing Strategies, Houghton-Mifflin Company, Boston, MA. Jensen, L. & Allen, M. (1996), "':-Feta-Synthesis of Qualitative Findings", Qualitative Health Research, 6(4) . Kannan, V . & Tan, K . (2002), "Supplier Selection and Assessment : Their Impact on Business Performance", Journal of Supply Chain Management, 38(4) . Kim, J ., Allenby, G. & Rossi, P. (2002), "Modelling Consumer Demand for Variety", Marketing Science., 2 1(3). Kerlinger, F. (1964), Foundations of Behavioural Research, Holt, New York . Khurrum S . & Faizul, H . (2002), "Supplier Selection Problem : A Comparison of the Total Cost of Ownership and Analytic Hierarchy Process Approaches", Supply Chain Management, 7(3/4). Kogut, B. (1985), "Designing Global Strategies: Comparative and Competitive Value-Added Chains", Sloan Management Review, 26(4) . Kollat, D ., Blackwell, R., & Robeson, J . (1972), Strategic Marketing Holt, Rinehart & Winston, New York . Kotabe, M . (1990), "The Relationship between Offshore Sourcing and Innovativeness of US Multinational Firms : An Empirical Investigation", Journal of International /Business Studies, 21(4) . Kotler . P. (1999), Now To Create, Win & Dominate Markets, Free Press, LISA . Kotler, P .. Adam, S ., Brown, L . & Armstrong, G, (2001), Principles of Marketing, Prentice-Hall, New York . Lassar, W. & Kerr, J . (1996), "Strategy and Control in Supplier-Distributor (Relationships ; An Agency Perspective", Strategic Management Journal, 17 . Lauder, D. (1993), New Strategies In Social Research, Polity Press : Cambridge. Len, L. (1. 997), "Targeting Technology", Progressive Grocer, 76(1) . Leguin,U ., (2001), The Birthday of the World: And Other stories, HarperCollins, New York Liesch, P . & Knight, G. (2002), "The Scale of the Firm, Its Internationalisation and the Worldwide Market for Transactions ", Working Paper, university of Queensland . Li K & Goffin(2001) “Manageing the Transition – Supplier Management in international Joint Ventures In China” International Journal of Physical Distribution Locke, D . (1996), "Global Supply Management - A Guide to International Purchasing" Mcgraw Hill , New York. Lowson R . (2001) "Retail Operational Strategies in Complex Supply Chains", International Journal of 'Logistics Management, 12(1) . Lysons, K. (1996), Purchasing - Fourth Edition, Financial Times, Pitman, London. Malina, M . & Selto, F . (2001), "Communicating and Controlling Strategy : An Empirical Study of the Effectiveness of the Balanced Scorecard" Journal of Management Research, (13) Martin, B . & Larsen, G . (1999), "Taming the Tiger: Key Success Factors for Trade With China", Marketing Intelligence and Planning, 17(4) . McAllister. D. (1995), "Affect and Cognition-Based Trust as Foundations for Interpersonal Cooperation in Organizations", Academy of Management Journal, 38 . McKinnon 4 (1996) "The Empty Running and Return Loading of Road Goods Vehicles", Transport Logistics, I (1) . Merrilees . B . and Tiessen, J . (1999), "Building Generalizable SME International Marketing Models Using Case Studies", International Marketing Review, 16(4/5) . Miles, M. & Huberman, M . (1994), Qualitative Data Analysis, Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications, USA . Data Analysis, An Expanded Sourcebook 2nd Edition Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications : CA, USA Miles. lvl. & Iluberman, M. (1994), Qualitative Data Analysis. An Expanded Sourcebook 2nd Edition. Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications : CA., USA . Milligan, J . (1987), "Specialty Shopping : Its Effective Promotion", Retail &Distribution Management, Sep . /Oct., 15(5). Min, H. & Galle, W. (1991), "International Purchasing Strategies of Multinational U. S . Finns", International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, 27(3) . Min H: (1994) "International Supplier Selection : A Multi-Attribute Approach", International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 24(5). Min, S . & Mentzer, J . (2000), "The Role of Marketing in Supply Chain Management", International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 30(9). Monczka, & Giunipero, L. (1984), "International Purchasing : Characteristics and Implementation", .Journal of Purchasing and ,Materials Management, Fall, 2(9)- Monczka, R. & Trent, R. (1991), "Global Sourcing: A Development Approach", International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, Spring, 27 . Morgan, R . & Hunt, S . (1994), "The Commitment Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing", Journal of Marketing, 58(30) . Moss, C. (2003). "Foreign Sourcing By U .S . Manufacturers", Small Business :Success America's Small Business Resource, 15 . Mostyn. B . (1985), The Content Analysis of Qualitative Research Data : A . The Research Interview : Uses and Approaches, Academic Press, .Dynamic Approach Orlando, Florida. Motwani, ,I . & Ahuja, .I. (2000), "International Purchasing Practices of US and Indian Managers: A Comparative Analysis", Industrial Management & Data Systems, 100(4) . Motwani, J., Madan, M., Jiang, J . & Otero, L . (1998), "International Purchasing Strategies of US and Puerto Rico Firms : A Comparative Empirical Analysis . Logistics Information Management, 11(3) . Muckstadt, J., Murray, D. & Rappold, J . (2000), The No B/C Production-Inventory Strategy, Working Paper, University of Wisconsin-Madison . Mummalaneni. V., Dubas, K. &. Chao, C. (1996), "Chinese Purchasing Managers' Preferences and Trade-Offs in Supplier Selection and Performance Evaluation", Industrial Marketing Management, 25. Murray, J . (2001), "Strategic Alliance - Based Global Sourcing Strategy for Competitive Advantage: A Conceptual Framework and Research Propositions" .Journal of International Marketing,9(4). Murray, S . (2004), " Importers Pay the P rice of Heavy Security", Financial Times, Jan ., 13 . Myers, T. (2003), "Logistics: International Crisis Boosts Supply Chain Integrity New Zealand's Trading History Gives Advantages In the New World of Tighter Border Controls", NZ Business, January . Neaman. L. (1999), Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative and Quantitative Approaches 5th Edition, Alyn aid Bacon, Boston Neaman. W . (2000), Social Research Methods - Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches . A Pearson Education Company, USA . Norquist, W . (1987) "Counter Trade: Another Horizon for Purchasing", Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, Summer, 2(6) . NZIER (1999), Consumer Benefits From Import Liberalisation: A New Zealand Case Study, NZ Institute of Economic Research. Ohmae, K. (1985), Triad Power: the Coming Shape of Global Competition, the Free Press, New York . Ohmae, K. (1990), The Borderless World : Power and Strategy in the Interlinked Economy, Harper Business, New York . Pache, G. (1998), "A Transactional Approach to Global Sourcing: Application To French good Retailers", British Food Journal, 100(9) . Pan, Y. & Li, X. (2000), "Joint Venture Formation of Very Large Multinational Finns", Journal of International Business Studies, 31(1) . Park, D & Krishnan., H (200