Low diagnostic value of fasting and post-methionine load homocysteine tests. A study in Dutch subjects with homocysteine test indications

BACKGROUND: Homocysteine is a cardiovascular disease risk factor. We investigated, both in subjects with past plasma total homocysteine (tHcy) test indications and healthy adults, the diagnostic value of a fasting (tHcy) (f-tHcy) and the added value of a post-methionine-load tHcy (postload-tHcy). METHODS: Plasma homocysteine cut-off values were retrospectively used for hyperhomocysteinemia assessment in 3477 subjects with past tHcy test indications and 177 apparently healthy subjects. Cut-off values were based on reference limits (f-tHcy < or = 15.0; postload-tHcy < or = 50.0 micro mol/l), relative risk (f-tHcy < or = 12.0, postload-tHcy < or = 38.0; or f-tHcy < or = 10.0 micro mol/l) and vitamin-optimized reference limits (f-tHcy < or = 9.3; postload-tHcy < or = 35.1 micro mol/l). RESULTS: Use of the American Heart Association 10 micro mol/l f-tHcy cut-off value gave hyperhomocysteinemia prevalences of 65% in subjects with past tHcy test indications and 50% in healthy subjects. The combination of the vitamin-optimized reference limits for f-tHcy and postload-tHcy gave a hyperhomocysteinemia prevalence of 79% in subjects with tHcy test indications, of which only 5% was on account of increased postload-tHcy. Corresponding values for healthy subjects were 68% and 3%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Employment of a 10 micro mol/l (American Heart Association) or 9.3 micro mol/l (vitamin-optimized reference) cut-off value leaves no indications for tHcy testing from an evidence-based point-of-view