Average Precision: Good Guide or False Friend to Multimedia Search Effectiveness?

Approaches to multimedia search often evolve from existing approaches with strong average precision. However, work on search evaluation shows that average precision does not always capture effectiveness in terms of satisfying user needs because it ignores the diversity of search results. This paper investigates whether search approaches with diverse results have been neglected within the multimedia retrieval research agenda due the fact that they are overshadowed by search approaches with strong average precision. To this end, we compare 361 search approaches applied on the TrecVid benchmarks between 2005 and 2007. We motivate two criteria based on measure correlation and statistical equivalence to estimate whether search approaches with diverse results have been neglected. We show that hypothesized effect indeed occurs in the above examined collections. As a consequence, the research community would benefit from reconsidering existing approaches in the light of diversity