Remifentanil versus Fentanyl/Midazolam in Painless Reduction of Anterior Shoulder Dislocation; a Randomized Clinical Trial

Introduction: Performance of painful diagnostic and therapeutic procedures is common in emergency department<br />(ED), and procedural sedation and analgesia (PSA) is a fundamental skill for every emergency physician.<br />This studywas aim to compare the efficacy of remifentanil with fentanyl/midazolam in painless reduction of anterior<br />shoulder dislocation. Methods: In this randomized, double blind, clinical trial the procedural characteristics,<br />patients satisfaction as well as adverse events were compared between fentanyl/midazolamand remifentanil<br />for PSA of 18–64 years old patients, which were presented to ED following anterior shoulder dislocation.<br />Results: 96 cases were randomly allocated to two groups (86.5% male). There were no significant difference between<br />groups regarding baseline characteristics. Remifentanil group had lower duration of procedure (2.5§1.6<br />versus 4.6§1.8 minutes, p Ç 0.001), higher pain reduction (53.7§13.3 versus 33.5§19.6, p Ç 0.001), lower failure<br />rate (1 (2.1%) versus 15 (31.3%), p Ç 0.001), higher satisfaction (p Æ 0.005). Adverse events were seen in 12 (25%)<br />patients in midazolam/fentanyl and 8 (16.7%) cases in remifentanil group (p Æ 0.122). Conclusion: It seems<br />that use of remifentanil resulted in lower procedural time, lower failure rate, and lower pain during procedure<br />as well as higher patient satisfaction in comparison with midazolam/fentanyl combination in anterior shoulder<br />dislocation