The extended evolutionary synthesis and the role of soft inheritance in evolution

In recent years a number of researchers have advocated extending the modern synthesis in evolutionary biology. One of the core arguments made in favour of an extension comes from work on soft inheritance systems including transgenerational epigenetic effects, cultural transmission, and niche construction. In this paper we outline this claim and then take issue with it. We argue that the focus upon soft inheritance has led to a conflation of proximate and ultimate causation, which has in turn obscured key questions about biological organization and calibration across the life-span to maximize average lifetime inclusive fitness. We illustrate this by presenting hypotheses that we believe incorporate the core phenomena of soft-inheritance and will aid in understanding them