Open side-to-side repair for non-repairable tendon-to-bone rotator cuff tear. Clinical and anatomic outcome at a mean 5 years’ follow-up

AbstractIntroductionAnatomical tendon-to-bone repair of retracted rotator cuff tear is a difficult challenge given the high rate of recurrence.HypothesisThe study hypothesis was that side-to-side repair of U-shaped retracted tear allows tendon healing with satisfactory medium-term clinical results.Materials and methodsBetween 1999 and 2007, 35patients (mean age 53.5years) were operated on with this open technique. On the De Orio and Cofield classification, tendon lesions were medium in 5cases, large in 25 and massive in 5. Subacromial space was in all cases greater than 7mm. Fatty infiltration grade was less than or equal to 2 on Goutallier's classification in all cases except for 1 grade3 (supraspinatus only). At last follow-up, patients were assessed clinically (Constant score) and radiographically. Tendon healing was assessed by ultrasound (31 cases) or CT-arthrography (4cases).ResultsMean follow-up was 60months. Constant score improved significantly, from 64.7±10 preoperatively to 77.1±14 postoperatively (P<0.05). Recurrence rate was 17.1%. Subacromial space was