Newton's solution to the equiangular spiral problem and a new solution using only the equiangular property

AbstractThis paper is a study of Proposition IX of Book I of Newton's Principia, the problem of determining the centripetal force for an equiangular spiral. In Newton's main proof of this proposition there is an error concerning his reason for the figure SPRQT being “given in kind,” and a very interesting technique of varying things in the neighborhood of a limit. This main proof utilized Newton's formula for the limit of SP2QT2QR given in Corollary I to Proposition VI of the Principia. Newton also gave an alternate proof which utilized his formula for SY2PV given in Corollary III to Proposition VI. The “given” of Proposition IX was “a spiral PQS, cutting all the radii SP, SQ, &c., in a given angle.” Both the main proof and the alternate proof implicitly depend on the property of the equiangular spiral that the radius of curvature at any point is proportional to the pole distance SP. We here offer a new proof of Newton's proposition which does not depend on this implicit assumption