Reexamining Bogoliubov’s theory of an interacting Bose gas, arXiv:cond-mat/ 0703498v1

As is well-known, in the conventional formulation of Bogoliubov’s theory of an interacting Bose gas, the Hamiltonian H ̂ is written as a decoupled sum of contributions from different momenta of the form H ̂ = P k=0 Ĥk. Then, each of the single-mode Hamiltonians Ĥk is diagonalized separately, and the resulting ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian H ̂ is written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of each of the single-mode Hamiltonians Ĥk. While this way of diagonalizing the total Hamiltonian H ̂ may seem to be valid from the perspective of the standard, number non-conserving Bogoliubov’s method, where the k = 0 state is removed from the Hilbert space and hence the individual Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {Ĥk} are diagonalized are disjoint from one another, we argue that from a number-conserving perspective this diagonalization method may not be adequate since the true Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {Ĥk} should be diagonalized all have the k = 0 state in common, and hence the ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian H ̂ may not be written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of the Ĥk’s. In this paper, we give a thorough review of Bogoliubov’s method, and discuss a variational and number-conserving formulation of this theory in which the k = 0 state is restored to the Hilbert space of the interacting gas, and where, instead of diagonalizing the Hamiltonians Ĥk separately, we diagonalize the total Hamiltonian H ̂ as a whole. When this is done, we find that the ground state energy is lowered below the Bogoliubov result, and the depletion of bosons is significantly reduced with respect to the one obtained in the number non-conserving treatment. We also find that the spectrum of the usual αk excitations of Bogoliubov’s method changes from a gapless one, as predicted by the standard, number non-conserving formulation of this theory, to one which exhibits a finite gap in the k → 0 limit. We discuss the presence of a gap in the spectrum of the αk’s in light of Goldstone’s theorem, and show that there is no contradiction with the latter