Stability and uniqueness of p-values for likelihood-based inference

Likelihood-based methods of statistical inference provide a useful general methodology that is appealing, as a straightforward asymptotic theory can be applied for their implementation. It is important to assess the relationships between different likelihood-based inferential procedures in terms of accuracy and adherence to key principles of statistical inference, in particular those relating to conditioning on relevant ancillary statistics. An analysis is given of the stability properties of a general class of likelihood-based statistics, including those derived from forms of adjusted profile likelihood, and comparisons are made between inferences derived from different statistics. In particular, we derive a set of sufficient conditions for agreement to Op(n-1), in terms of the sample size n, of inferences, specifically p-values, derived from different asymptotically standard normal pivots. Our analysis includes inference problems concerning a scalar or vector interest parameter, in the presence of a nuisance parameter