Detection and classification of nonlinearities in motion systems becomes of increasing importance with high demands on (closed loop) performance. In this paper two methods are compared that aim to measure both the linearized dynamics and the influence of nonlinearities. First, a broadband signal is used to measure a linear approximation of the systems dynamics. This method uses multisine signals with identical amplitude spectrum, but randomly distributed phases. Averaging over multiple periodic responses to the same signal and over multiple realizations of the random phase multisine allows the computation of the level of nonlinearities and external disturbances separately. This yields both a linear approximation of the systems dynamics and ...