Determinants of between-hospital variations in outcomes for patients admitted with COPD exacerbations: findings from a nationwide clinical audit (AUDIPOC) in Spain

Background Previous studies have demonstrated significant variability in the processes of care and outcomes of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbations. The AUDIPOC is a Spanish nationwide clinical audit that identified large between-hospital variations in care and clinical outcomes. Here, we test the hypothesis that these variations can be attributed to either patient characteristics, hospital characteristics and/or the so-called hospital-clustering effect, which indicates that patients with similar characteristics may experience different processes of care and outcomes depending on the hospital to which they are admitted. Methods A clinical audit of 5178 COPD patients consecutively admitted to 129 Spanish public hospitals was performed, with a 90-day follow-up. Multilevel regression analysis was conducted to model the probability of patients experiencing adverse outcomes. For each outcome, an empty model (with no independent variables) was fitted to assess the clustering effect, followed by a model adjusted for the patient- and hospital-level covariables. The hospital-clustering effect was estimated using the intracluster correlation coefficient (ICC); the cluster heterogeneity was estimated with the median odds ratio (MOR), and the coefficients of predictors were estimated with the odds ratio (OR). Results In the empty models, the ICC (MOR) for inpatient mortality and the follow-up mortality and readmission were 0.10 (1.80), 0.08 (1.65) and 0.01 (1.24), respectively. In the adjusted models, the variables that most represented the patients’ clinical conditions and interventions were identified as outcome predictors and further reduced the hospital variations. By contrast, the resource factors were primarily unrelated with outcomes. Conclusions This study demonstrates a noteworthy reduction in the observed crude between-hospital variation in outcomes after accounting for the hospital-cluster effect and the variables representing patient's clinical conditions. This emphasises the predictor importance of the patients’ clinical conditions and interventions, and understates the impacts of hospital resources and organisational factors.Authors thank all participating institutions for their willingness to contribute to medical research aimed at reducing medical practice variations, improving the quality of care provided. Supported by the Spanish Ministry of Health, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, FIS project numbers: PI07/90129, PI07/90309, PI07/90486, PI07/90503, PI07/90516, PI07/90721, PI08/90129, PI08/90578, PI08/90251, PI08/90529, PI08/90129, PI07/90403, PI08/90447, PI08/90457, PI08/90486 and PI08/90550, the Centro de Investigación Biomédica en Red de Enfermedades Respiratorias (CIBERES) and the Spanish Society of Respiratory and Thoracic Surgey (SEPAR)