ABSTRACT Thymidylate kinases (TMPKs) play an essential role in DNA biosynthesis across all domains of life by catalyzing dTMP phosphorylation to dTDP. In Pseudomonas putida KT2440, a model Gram-negative soil bacterium, tmk is disrupted by a 65-kb genomic island (GI), posing questions about the origin of the essential TMPK function. To solve this long-standing evolutionary riddle, we addressed three competing hypotheses: (i) assembly of two Tmk segments into a functional protein, (ii) complementation by a deoxynucleotide monophosphate kinase encoded within the GI, or (iii) fulfillment of the essential function by the product of PP_3363, yet another gene annotated as “thymidylate kinase.” Systematic genome engineering, quantitative physiology...