Underrepresented controls of aridity in climate sensitivity of carbon cycle models

Travail scientifique posté sur Research SquareTerrestrial ecosystems respond to changes in environmental conditions, mainly via key climatic controls of precipitation and temperature on vegetation activities and decomposition processes (Taylor et al., 2017). Yet, the relationship between climate and the overall spatiotemporal dynamics and uncertainties of the global carbon cycle, i.e., gross primary productivity (GPP), effective ecosystem carbon turnover times (τ), and consequently the total ecosystem carbon stock (Ctotal), are unclear (Anav et al., 2013; Friedlingstein et al., 2014; Friend et al., 2014; Jones et al., 2013). Using a global observation-based synthesis, we first show that the apparent partial spatial climate sensitivities of GPP and τ are associated with relative availability of precipitation and temperature, and are therefore modulated by aridity. The apparent sensitivity of GPP to temperature increases from arid to humid climatic regions. In contrast, its sensitivity to precipitation is invariant throughout different climatic regions. Simultaneously, the τ-precipitation response is strongly non-linear resulting in ~2 times longer τ in arid regions compared to humid regions for a given temperature. Compared with these observed patterns, the offline carbon cycle simulations of seven European Earth System Models (ESMs), that participated in CMIP6, perform relatively better for climate sensitivities of GPP than those of τ. This leads to a large spread and bias in Ctotal in both warm and cold semi-arid and arid regions where only a few models capture the observed τ-precipitation relationship. The emergence of the hydrological controls, modulated by aridity, on global carbon cycle implies that the changes in precipitation may moderate the temperature-driven climate feedback of the global carbon cycle under climate change