Discourse Comprehension and Informational Masking: The Effect of Age, Semantic Content, and Acoustic Similarity

It is often difficult for people to understand speech when there are other ongoing conversations in the background. This dissertation investigates how different background maskers interfere with our ability to comprehend speech and the reasons why older listeners have more difficulties than younger listeners in these tasks. An ecologically valid approach was applied: instead of words or short sentences, participants were presented with two fairly lengthy lectures simultaneously, and their task was to listen to the target lecture, and ignore the competing one. Afterwards, they answered questions regarding the target lecture. Experiment 1 found that both normal-hearing and hearing-impaired older adults performed poorer than younger adults when everyone was tested in identical listening situations. However, when the listening situation was individually adjusted to compensate for age-related differences in the ability to recognize individual words in noise, age-related difference in comprehension disappeared. Experiment 2 compared the masking effects of a single-talker competing lecture to a babble of 12 voices, and the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) was manipulated so that the masker was either of similar volume as the target, or much louder. The results showed that the competing speech was much more distracting than babble. Moreover, increasing the masker level negatively affected speech comprehension only when the masker was babble; when it was a single-talker lecture, the performance plateaued as the SNR decreased from -2 to -12 dB. Experiment 3 compared the effects of semantic content and acoustic similarity on speech comprehension by comparing a normal speech masker with a time-reversed one (to examine the effect of semantic content) and a normal speech masker with an 8-band vocoded speech (to examine the effect of acoustic similarity). The results showed that both semantic content and acoustic similarity contributed to informational masking, but the latter seemed to play a bigger role than the former. Together, the results indicated that older adults’ speech comprehension difficulties with maskers were mainly due to declines in their hearing capacities rather than their cognitive functions. The acoustic similarity between the target and competing speech may be the main reason for informational masking, with semantic interference playing a secondary role.Ph