Sources of the nation, a comparative analysis of the origins of national sentiment in Alsace and Quebec

grantor: University of TorontoThis work attempts to understand why some culturally distinct groups develop their own nationalist movement while other similarly distinct groups content themselves with identifying with their larger nation-state. I compare the genesis of the national sentiments of two distinct collectivities selected because of their divergent national trajectories: while Quebec experienced its own national movement in the early nineteenth century, Alsace, despite its marked Germanity, developed a French national sentiment roughly in the same period. Chapter 1 shows the contributions and limits of the existing literature on nationalism. Chapter 2 elaborates a cultural-historical neoinstitutionalist model of nationalism based on two premises: (1) the individuals' existential dependence on their institutional environment; and (2) the affirmation of subjectivity as the essence of modernity. The emergence of the national sentiment is generated by the unprecedented diffusion among the masses of principles of personal autonomy, equality, and popular sovereignty. This diffusion gives rise both to a demand for popular control of the state and, as a result of the formation of public discursive spheres, to a process of societal self-awareness. Nationalism characterises this self-aware society's aspiration to sovereignty, while the national sentiment depicts 'homo nationalis'' existential dependence on a given society's public spirit. The eventual presence or absence of nationalism is determined by the institutional order in place at the time of the masses' transition to modernity. Chapter 3 describes the absence of nationalism in prerevolutionary Alsace and Quebec. Chapter 4 interprets the emergence of the (political) nation in both contexts as a result of revolutions. Chapter 5 explores the process of societal self-awareness taking place in early nineteenth century Alsace and Quebec. While, as a result of their institutional segregation, French Canadians became gradually aware of their distinct societal existence, Alsatians, because of their violent inclusion in the French revolutionary order, slowly realised their membership in the French discursive sphere. This resulted in the construction and adoption by both Alsatians and French Canadians of (contingent) national symbols and narratives conforming to their respective aspirations to sovereignty: while Alsatians imagined themselves as French nationals, French Canadians literally invented French Canada.Ph.D