Indonesia is a famously religious nation that has a high-level of plurality in many aspects of race/ethnicity, religion, belief, language, customs, political thoughts, economic, cultural and ideological. All these could potentially contribute conflict and tension between different groups if the attitude of extreme and formalistic logic of fiqh flourished. This paper tryies to emphasize the importance of fiqh aqalliyah in the era of pluralism to organize the life among different religious believers in which religious conflict has often been the case due to double standards and the Islamic militant movement. By means of Kuhn’s shifting paradigm approach, this paper reveals that Muslims need to formulate a shifting paradigm of ijtihad, namely...