Taxonomic identification using virtual palaeontology and geometric morphometrics: a case study of Jurassic nerineoidean gastropods

Taxonomic identification of fossils is fundamental to a wide range of geological and biological disciplines. Many fossil groups are identified based on expert judgment, which requires extensive experience and is not always available for the specific taxonomic group at hand. Nerineoideans, a group of extinct gastropods that formed a major component of Mesozoic shallow marine environments, have distinctive internal spiral folds that form the basis for their classification at the genus level. However, their identification is often inconsistent because it is based on a set of selected characters reliant upon individual interpretation. This study shows a non-destructive and quantitative method for their identification using micro-CT and geometric morphometrics. We examined and micro-CT-scanned nerineoidean specimens from five main families that dominated Europe, Arabia and Africa during the Middle-Late Jurassic. Optimal longitudinal slices were selected from the tomographic reconstructions or from images of polished cross-sections compiled from fossil collections, published work and online databases. Internal whorl outlines were represented by thirty evenly distributed sliding semilandmarks and shape variations were studied using the Procrustes-based geometric morphometrics method. Multivariate analysis shows that Ceritellidae and Ptygmatididae are distinct families, whereas Nerinellidae, Eunerineidae and Nerineidae fall within the same shape variance and cannot be distinguished based on internal whorl outlines. The suggested method can be applied to images from various sources as well as to poorly preserved specimens. Our case study demonstrates the importance of quantitatively re-evaluating taxonomy in the fossil record, promoting the future utility of large datasets.See attached README file for additional information.Fifty-eight specimens were examined from a wide range of Middle and Upper Jurassic palaeo-latitudes from Europe, Asia (Arabia) and Africa in order to capture a wide range of cross-sectional shell morphologies from across the Tethys shelf. Five of the seven known nerineoidean families in the Tethys Sea were included in the analysis: Ceritellidae Wenz, 1940, Ptygmatididae Pchelintsev, 1960, Nerinellidae Pchelintsev, 1960, Eunerineidae Kollmann, 2014 and Nerineidae Zittel, 1873. Twenty-eight of the specimens were scanned at the Natural History Museum (London, UK) using a micro-CT, and the rest were analyzed using images of polished cross-sections compiled from various sources