Incompleteness of complete pseudoscalar-meson photoproduction

Background: A complete set is a minimum set of observables which allows one to determine the underlying reaction amplitudes unambiguously. Pseudoscalar-meson photoproduction from the nucleon is characterized by four such amplitudes and complete sets involve single- and double-polarization observables. Purpose: Identify complete sets of observables and study how measurements with finite error bars impact their potential to determine the reaction amplitudes unambiguously. Method: The authors provide arguments to employ the transversity representation in order to determine the amplitudes in pseudoscalar-meson photoproduction. It is studied whether the amplitudes in the transversity basis for the gamma p -> K+ Lambda reaction can be estimated without ambiguity. To this end, data from the GRAAL collaboration and simulations from a realistic model are analyzed. Results: It is illustrated that the moduli of normalized transversity amplitudes can be determined from precise single-polarization data. Starting from simulations with achievable experimental resolution, it is quite likely to obtain imaginary solutions for the relative phases of the amplitudes. Also the real solutions face a discrete phase ambiguity which makes it impossible to obtain a statistically significant solution for the relative phases at realistic experimental conditions. Conclusions: Single polarization observables are effective in determining the moduli of the amplitudes in a transversity basis. Determining the relative phases of the amplitudes from double-polarization observables is far less evident. The availability of a complete set of observables does not allow one to unambiguously determine the reaction amplitudes with statistical significance.Background: A complete set is a minimum set of observables which allows one to determine the underlying reaction amplitudes unambiguously. Pseudoscalar-meson photoproduction from the nucleon is characterized by four such amplitudes and complete sets involve single- and double-polarization observables. Purpose: Identify complete sets of observables and study how measurements with finite error bars impact their potential to determine the reaction amplitudes unambiguously. Method: The authors provide arguments to employ the transversity representation in order to determine the amplitudes in pseudoscalar-meson photoproduction. It is studied whether the amplitudes in the transversity basis for the gamma p -> K+ Lambda reaction can be estimated without ambiguity. To this end, data from the GRAAL collaboration and simulations from a realistic model are analyzed. Results: It is illustrated that the moduli of normalized transversity amplitudes can be determined from precise single-polarization data. Starting from simulations with achievable experimental resolution, it is quite likely to obtain imaginary solutions for the relative phases of the amplitudes. Also the real solutions face a discrete phase ambiguity which makes it impossible to obtain a statistically significant solution for the relative phases at realistic experimental conditions. Conclusions: Single polarization observables are effective in determining the moduli of the amplitudes in a transversity basis. Determining the relative phases of the amplitudes from double-polarization observables is far less evident. The availability of a complete set of observables does not allow one to unambiguously determine the reaction amplitudes with statistical significance.A