Vanishing spin stiffness in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain for any nonzero temperature

Whether at the zero spin density m = 0 and finite temperatures T > 0 the spin stiffness of the spin-1/2 XXX chain is finite or vanishes remains an unsolved and controversial issue, as different approaches yield contradictory results. Here we explicitly compute the stiffness at m = 0 and find strong evidence that it vanishes. In particular, we derive an upper bound on the stiffness within a canonical ensemble at any fixed value of spin density m that is proportional to m2L in the thermodynamic limit of chain length L → ∞, for any finite, nonzero temperature, which implies the absence of ballistic transport for T > 0 for m = 0. Although our method relies in part on the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz (TBA), it does not evaluate the stiffness through the second derivative of the TBA energy eigenvalues relative to a uniform vector potential. Moreover, we provide strong evidence that in the thermodynamic limit the upper bounds on the spin current and stiffness used in our derivation remain valid under string deviations. Our results also provide strong evidence that in the thermodynamic limit the TBA method used by X. Zotos [Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 1764 (1999)] leads to the exact stiffness values at finite temperature T > 0 for models whose stiffness is finite at T = 0, similar to the spin stiffness of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain but unlike the charge stiffness of the half-filled 1D Hubbard model.We thank Henrik Johannesson, Pedro D. Sacramento, Steven R. White, and Xenophon Zotos for discussions. J.M.P.C. thanks the support by the Beijing CSRC and the Portuguese FCT through the Grant PEST-C/FIS/UI0607/2013. T.P. acknowledges support by Slovenian ARRS Grant No. P1-0044. D.K.C. acknowledges the hospitality of the International Institute of Physics at the Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte in Natal, Brazil, where part of this work was conducted