Differentiation of Perilesional Edema in Glioblastomas and Brain Metastases: Comparison of Diffusion Tensor Imaging, Neurite Orientation Dispersion and Density Imaging and Diffusion Microstructure Imaging

Although the free water content within the perilesional T2 hyperintense region should differ between glioblastomas (GBM) and brain metastases based on histological differences, the application of classical MR diffusion models has led to inconsistent results regarding the differentiation between these two entities. Whereas diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) considers the voxel as a single compartment, multicompartment approaches such as neurite orientation dispersion and density imaging (NODDI) or the recently introduced diffusion microstructure imaging (DMI) allow for the calculation of the relative proportions of intra- and extra-axonal and also free water compartments in brain tissue. We investigate the potential of water-sensitive DTI, NODDI and DMI metrics to detect differences in free water content of the perilesional T2 hyperintense area between histopathologically confirmed GBM and brain metastases. Respective diffusion metrics most susceptible to alterations in the free water content (MD, V-ISO, V-CSF) were extracted from T2 hyperintense perilesional areas, normalized and compared in 24 patients with GBM and 25 with brain metastases. DTI MD was significantly increased in metastases (p = 0.006) compared to GBM, which was corroborated by an increased DMI V-CSF (p = 0.001), while the NODDI-derived ISO-VF showed only trend level increase in metastases not reaching significance (p = 0.060). In conclusion, diffusion MRI metrics are able to detect subtle differences in the free water content of perilesional T2 hyperintense areas in GBM and metastases, whereas DMI seems to be superior to DTI and NODDI