Ring-Exchange Interaction Effects on Magnons in Dirac Magnet CoTiO$_3$

In magnetically ordered materials with localized electrons, the fundamental magnetic interactions are due to exchange of electrons [1-3]. Typically, only the interaction between pairs of electrons' spins is considered to explain the nature of the ground state and its excitations, whereas three-, four-, and six-spin interactions are ignored. When these higher order processes occur in a loop they are called cyclic or ring exchange. The ring-exchange interaction is required to explain low temperature behavior in bulk and thin films of solid $^3$He [4-8]. It also plays a crucial role in the quantum magnet La$_2$CuO$_4$ [9,10]. Here, we use a combination of time domain THz (TDTS) and magneto-Raman spectroscopies to measure the low energy magnetic excitations in CoTiO$_3$, a proposed Dirac topological magnon material [11,12] where the origin of the energy gap in the magnon spectrum at the Brillouin zone center remains unclear. We measured the magnetic field dependence of the energies of the two lowest energy magnons and determine that the gap opens due to the ring-exchange interaction between the six spins in a hexagon. This interaction also explains the selection rules of the THz magnon absorption. Finally, we clarify that topological surface magnons are not expected in CoTiO$_3$. Our study demonstrates the power of combining TDTS and Raman spectroscopies with theory to identify the microscopic origins of the magnetic excitations in quantum magnets.Comment: 7 pages, 4 figures in main text, 26 pages and 11 figures in supplemen