Chiari 1 Malformation and Epilepsy in Children: A Missing Relationship

Purpose: Once believed a result of pathophysiological correlations, the association between Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) and epilepsy has since been considered as a coincidence, due to missing etiologic or clinical matching points. At present, the problem is being newly debated because of the increasing number of CM1 diagnoses, often among children with seizures. No specific studies on this topic are available yet. The present study aimed at updating the information on this topic by reporting on a series of children specifically enrolled and retrospectively analyzed for this purpose. Methods: All children admitted between January 2015 and June 2020 for epilepsy and CM1 were considered (Group 1). They were compared with children admitted in the same period for symptoms/signs related to CM1 and/or syringomyelia (Group 2). Syndromic patients were excluded, as well as those with tumoral or other overt intracranial lesions. All patients received a complete preoperative work-up, including MRI and EEG. Symptomatic children with CM1/syringomyelia were operated on. The pertinent literature was reviewed. Results: Group 1 was composed of 29 children (mean age: 6.2 years) showing CM1 and epilepsy with several types of seizures. A share of 27% had CM1-related symptoms and syringomyelia. The mean tonsillar ectopia was 7.5 mm. Surgery was performed in 31% of cases. Overall, 62% of children are currently seizure-free (including 5/9 children who were operated on). Tonsillar herniation and syringomyelia regressed in 4/9 cases and 4/8 cases, improved in 4/9 cases and 3/8 cases, and remained stable in 1/9 and 1/8 cases, respectively. CM1 signs/symptoms regressed completely in 6/8 cases and improved or remained stable in one case in each of the two remaining patients. Group 2 consisted of 77 children (mean age: 8.9 years) showing symptoms of CM1 (75%) and/or syringomyelia (39%). The mean tonsillar ectopia was 11.8 mm. Non-specific EEG anomalies were detected in 13 children (17%). Surgery was performed in 76.5% of cases (18 children were not operated on because of oligosymptomatic). Preoperative symptoms regressed in 26%, improved in 50%, remained stable 22%, and worsened in 2%; CM1 radiologically regressed in 39%, improved in 37%, remained unchanged in 22%, and worsened in 2%; and syringomyelia/hydromyelia regressed in 61%, improved in 30%, and was stable in 9%. No statistically significant differences between the two groups were detected regarding the M/F ratio, presence of syringomyelia/hydromyelia, or CM1/syringomyelia outcome; moreover, no correlation occurred between seizure-free condition and PF decompression in Group 1, or between disappearance of EEG anomalies and PF decompression in Group 2. A significant difference between the two groups was noticed regarding the mean age at admission (p = 0.003), amount of tonsillar herniation (p p = 0.0001). Conclusions: These findings do not support clinical correlations between CM1 and epilepsy. Their course depends on surgery and antiepileptic drugs, respectively. The analysis of the literature does not provide evidence of a relationship between seizures and cerebellar anomalies such as CM1. Rather than being linked to a syndrome that could explain such an association, the connection between the two now has to be considered to be random