Survival patterns of macrobenthic marine assemblages during the end-Permian mass extinction in the western Tethys (Dolomites, Italy)

The ecological competition between brachiopods and bivalves is analysed by means of a quantitative palaeoecologic method applied on four assemblages located within a short stratigraphic interval, approximately 2mthick, in the lower TeseroMember of theWerfen Formation (in the Southern Alps). The assemblages originate fromthe Tesero, Bulla and Sass de Putia sections. The analysed stratigraphic interval, uppermost Changhsingian in age, is located between the early and heaviest phase of the end-Permian mass extinction, which occurred across the Bellerophon/Werfen formational boundary (Event Boundary), and the Permian/Triassic boundary (Chronological Boundary), when nearly all the Permian stenotopic holdovers disappeared. These assemblages are characterised by small sized skeletons (“Lilliput effect”), which represent an adaptive survival strategy in stressed and harsh habitats resulting from the climatic and palaeoceanographic changes connected with the mass extinction. The Tesero assemblages are dominated by rhynchonelliform brachiopod Orbicoelia (bed CNT10) or Streptorhynchus (bed CNT11A), which were mostly attached at the top of shallow microbialitic mounds. These assemblages are again dominated by Permian stenotopic taxa and showa Palaeozoic structure. The Tesero habitat, which again permitted the survival of brachiopods, represented one of the last refuges in the western Tethys. On the contrary, the Bulla (BU9-10) and Sass de Putia (wPK13A) assemblages are bivalve-dominated, and thus show an ecologic structure typical of Early Triassic post-extinction marine benthic communities or Palaeozoic stressed marine communities. The bivalve-dominated assemblages proliferated in prevailing muddy siliciclastic substrates, with brief episodes of microbial algal growth. The most important environmental limiting factors and leading causes of end-Permian mass extinction are discussed in terms of palaeoautecologic and palaeosynecologic analysis. The different taxonomic composition and ecologic structure of the assemblages is related to palaeogeography, including water depth and connections with the open sea. The brachiopod-dominated assemblage, exclusive of the Tesero section, proliferated in microbial carbonate habitats in near-shore environments. The bivalvedominated assemblages, which were more widespread than the brachiopod assemblages in the Dolomites and also occurred in other western Tethys localities, occur in more open and deeper marine environments. In the western Tethys margins, the local distribution of mixed faunas suggests that the extinction of Permian stenotopic taxa was caused by the onset of poisonous water on the shelves originating from deep marine environments. This extinction pattern appears to be a regional phenomenon and does not seem be applicable on a global scale. The extinction events were controlled by a complex network of interactive factors and the survival of faunal elements was probably stochastic