Low-Power Random Access for Timely Status Update: Packet-based or Connection-based?

This paper investigates low-power random access protocols for timely status update systems with age of information (AoI) requirements. AoI characterizes information freshness, formally defined as the time elapsed since the generation of the last successfully received update. Considering an extensive network, a fundamental problem is how to schedule massive transmitters to access the wireless channel to achieve low network-wide AoI and high energy efficiency. In conventional packet-based random access protocols, transmitters contend for the channel by sending the whole data packet. When the packet duration is long, the time and transmit power wasted due to packet collisions is considerable. In contrast, connection-based random access protocols first establish connections with the receiver before the data packet is transmitted. Intuitively, from an information freshness perspective, there should be conditions favoring either side. This paper presents a comparative study of the average AoI of packet-based and connection-based random access protocols, given an average transmit power budget. Specifically, we consider slotted Aloha (SA) and frame slotted Aloha (FSA) as representatives of packet-based random access and design a request-then-access (RTA) protocol to study the AoI of connection-based random access. We derive closed-form average AoI and average transmit power consumption formulas for different protocols. Our analyses indicate that the use of packet-based or connection-based protocols depends mainly on the payload size of update packets and the transmit power budget. In particular, RTA saves power and reduces AoI significantly, especially when the payload size is large. Overall, our investigation provides insights into the practical design of random access protocols for low-power timely status update systems