Role of mutilating surgery in the treatment of non-chemosensitive pediatric soft tissue sarcomas. Experience of the Italian Cooperative Group Studies RMS-79 and RMS-88

Aim of the study was to evaluate the role of mutilating surgery in the patients with non chemosensitive soft tissue sarcomas (STS) registered in the Italian Studies. Between 1979 and 1995, 114 patients (pts) with "non chemosensitive" localized STS were enrolled in the cooperative studies RMS-79 (33) and RMS-88 (81). Median age: 89 months (range 1-194). Histology: fibrosarcoma 29, Malignant Perpheral Nerve Sheath Tumors (MPNST) 40, malignant fibrous histiocytoma 5, hemangiopericytoma 6, leiomyosarcoma 4, others 20, STS nos 10. The cases were classified according to the IRS staging system as Gr. I 46, Gr. II 24, Gr. III 44. Twelve out of 114 pts (7%), 5/33 (14%) in the first study and 7/81 (8%) in the second, underwent mutilating surgery: 8 pts (of whom 3 were < 2 y of age) had a fibrosarcoma and 4 a MPNST. The mutilating procedure was carried out at diagnosis in 6 cases (4 in RMS-79 and 2 in RMS-and 88) and achieved radicality in 5/6 cases. It was performed after ineffective chemotherapy (CT) in 5 pts (1 in RMS-79 and 4 in RMS-88). One pt (RMS-88) underwent mutilation after multiple local recurrences treated with CT, radiotherapy and conservative excisions (RMS-88) and died. The procedures consisted of 5 amputations, 4 demolitive excisions of extremities with functional impairment, 1 nephrectomy, 1 excision of deferents with spermatic vesicae and 1 mastectomy. OUTCOME: At present 6/12 pts, 5 with fibrosarcoma and 1 with MPNST, are alive with no evidence of disease (NED), 4 of the first and 2 of the second study. Of the 5 Gr. I patients, 4 are alive (NED) and 1 died of 2nd tumor; 1 Gr. II pt is alive NED; of the 5 Gr. III pts 1 is alive NED and 4 died (3 of metastatic spread and 1 of 2nd tumor); the pt amputated after repeated local relapses (Gr. II) is dead of pulmonary metastases. CONCLUSIONS: In the RMS-79 study the mutilations were frequent and were performed at diagnosis in several cases; this trend decreased in the 2nd study in which chemotherapy was attempted in most of the patients. Probably the timing of mutilating procedures was not always adequate (too early or too late). The outcome of pts undergone mutilations is similar to that of the whole group of 114 pts, whose overall survival at 10 years is 64% (C.I. 60-77). Only fibrosarcomas and MPNST probably requires a more aggressive surgical behaviour. At present we avoid initial demolitive surgery; it should be planned without delay after the first local relapse or after initial ineffective CT and RT