Measuring the elastic modulus of soft biomaterials using nanoindentation

The measurement of the elastic modulus of soft biomaterials via nanoindentation relies on the accurate determination of the zero-point of the tip-sample interaction on which the depth of penetration into the sample is based. Non-cantilever based nanoindentation systems were originally designed for hard materials, and therefore monitoring the zero-point contact presents a significant challenge for the characterisation of very soft biomaterials. This study investigates the ability of non-cantilever based nanoindentation to differentiate between hydrogels with elastic moduli on the order of single kiloPascals (kPa) using a bespoke soft contact protocol and low flexural stiffness of instrument. Polyethylene glycol (PEG) hydrogels were fabricated as a model system with a range of elastic moduli by varying the polymer concentration and degree of crosslinking. Elastic modulus values were calculated using the Oliver-Pharr method, Hertzian contact model, as well as a viscoelastic model to account for the time-dependent behaviour of the gels. The stiffness measurements were validated by measuring cantilever beams with the equivalent flexural stiffness to that of the PEG hydrogels being tested. The results demonstrated a high repeatability of the measurements, enabling differentiation between hydrogels with elastic moduli in the single kPa to hundreds of kPa range