Stable approximation of Helmholtz solutions in the disk by evanescent plane waves

Superpositions of plane waves are known to approximate well the solutions of the Helmholtz equation. Their use in discretizations is typical of Trefftz methods for Helmholtz problems, aiming to achieve high accuracy with a small number of degrees of freedom. However, Trefftz methods lead to ill-conditioned linear systems, and it is often impossible to obtain the desired accuracy in floating-point arithmetic. In this paper we show that a judicious choice of plane waves can ensure high-accuracy solutions in a numerically stable way, in spite of having to solve such ill-conditioned systems. Numerical accuracy of plane wave methods is linked not only to the approximation space, but also to the size of the coefficients in the plane wave expansion. We show that the use of plane waves can lead to exponentially large coefficients, regardless of the orientations and the number of plane waves, and this causes numerical instability. We prove that all Helmholtz fields are continuous superposition of evanescent plane waves, i.e., plane waves with complex propagation vectors associated with exponential decay, and show that this leads to bounded representations. We provide a constructive scheme to select a set of real and complex-valued propagation vectors numerically. This results in an explicit selection of plane waves and an associated Trefftz method that achieves accuracy and stability. The theoretical analysis is provided for a two-dimensional domain with circular shape. However, the principles are general and we conclude the paper with a numerical experiment demonstrating practical applicability also for polygonal domains