On the List Color Function Threshold

The chromatic polynomial of a graph $G$, denoted $P(G,m)$, is equal to the number of proper $m$-colorings of $G$. The list color function of graph $G$, denoted $P_{\ell}(G,m)$, is a list analogue of the chromatic polynomial that has been studied since the early 1990s, primarily through comparisons with the corresponding chromatic polynomial. It is known that for any graph $G$ there is a $k \in \mathbb{N}$ such that $P_\ell(G,m) = P(G,m)$ whenever $m \geq k$. The list color function threshold of $G$, denoted $\tau(G)$, is the smallest $k \geq \chi(G)$ such that $P_{\ell}(G,m) = P(G,m)$ whenever $m \geq k$. In 2009, Thomassen asked whether there is a universal constant $\alpha$ such that for any graph $G$, $\tau(G) \leq \chi_{\ell}(G) + \alpha$, where $\chi_{\ell}(G)$ is the list chromatic number of $G$. We show that the answer to this question is no by proving that there exists a constant $C$ such that $\tau(K_{2,l}) - \chi_{\ell}(K_{2,l}) \ge C\sqrt{l}$ for $l \ge 16$.Comment: 11 page