Highlights • Chlorine isotopes were measured in melt inclusions along CAVA. • Melt inclusions have on average higher Cl than bulk rocks. • Aqueous fluids, melt-like component and metasomatized mantle form three distinct signatures. • The high Cl of the metasomatized mantle wedge suggests the presence of amphibole. • The amphibole signature in bulk rocks is diluted by late-stage processes. The isotopic composition of Cl, a highly hydrophilic and incompatible element, can provide new insights into the processes of element recycling in subduction zone settings. Samples from 13 localities in Guatemala, El Salvador, Nicaragua and Costa Rica, representing a ca. 1000 km long NW-SE segment along the Central American Volcanic Arc (...