Environmental drivers for persistence of Escherischia coli and Salmonella in manure-amended soils: A meta-analysis.

Application of organic amendments to agricultural land improves soil quality and provides nutrients essential for plant growth; however, they are also a reservoir for zoonotic pathogens whose presence poses a significant risk to public health. Thepersistence of bacteria in manure-amended soil, and differences in manure handling practices, are important issues from a food safety perspective. The primary objective of this study was to quantitatively summarize the variations in the rate of decline of Escherichia coli and Salmonella spp. in manure-amended soil under laboratory and field conditions, and to assess the impact of environmental factors. Available literature data on persistence of E. coli and Salmonella spp. in manure-amended soil from 42 primary research studies were extracted and statistically analyzed using a mixed-effect regression model. The results indicated that temperature (soil and air combined) was the most prominent factor affecting persistence of both E. coli and Salmonella spp. under laboratory conditions (P , 0.001), and of E. coli under field conditions (P , 0.05). The time required for a log reduction of E. coli under field conditions was significantly higher at low temperature (0 to 108C) than at high temperature (greater than 208C) (P , 0.05). In addition, application method was identified as a significant factor, with manure incorporation to soil inducing longer survival compared with surface application by approximately 1.2 times. The significant variation observed among primary research studies of bacterial persistence has highlighted that mitigation strategies associated with the use of manures in fresh produce production need to be improved by addressing factors such as climate, soil management, application method, and initial microbial levels. These findings may be used to support guidelines establishing exclusion periods between manure fertilization and the grazing or harvesting of crops, and may be useful for the generation of quantitative microbial risk models for fresh produce