Add to ORKGIn this thesis, I raise considerations against some arguments that support evidentialism, the view that all normative reasons for belief are evidential reasons. In the first part of the thesis I lay out the main evidentialist claims I will be concerned with, and explain the significance of evidentialism for the ethics of belief. In the second part, I provide some considerations against a number of moral evidentialist arguments. In part three, I consider an argument for evidentialism based on common epistemic practices, and I explain how rejecting evidentialism is consistent with those practices. In part four, I lay out some value-based arguments against evidentialism. Finally, in part five, I try to show that arguments from the phenomenon o...