Maximal Causal Models for Sequentially Consistent Multithreaded Systems

This paper shows that it is possible to build a theoretically maximal and sound causal model for concurrent computations from a given execution trace. For an observed execution, the proposed model comprises all consistent executions which can be derived from it using only knowledge about the execution machine. The existence of such a model is of great theoretical value. First, by comprising all feasible executions, it can be used to prove soundness of other causal models: indeed, several models underlying existing techniques are shown to be embedded into the maximal model, so all these models are sound. Second, since it is maximal, the proposed model allows for natural and causal-model-independent de???nitions of trace-based properties; this paper proposes maximal de???nitions for causal dataraces and causal atomicity. Finally, although de???ned axiomatically, the set of traces comprised by the proposed model are shown to be e???ectively constructed from an initial observed trace. Thus, maximal causal models are not only theoretically relevant, but they are also amenable for developing practical analysis tools.unpublishednot peer reviewe