The Late-T Dwarf Companion to the Exoplanet Host Star HD 3651: A New Benchmark for Gravity and Metallicity Effects in Ultracool Spectra

(Abridged) We present near-IR photometry and spectroscopy of HD 3651B, the low-luminosity, wide-separation (480 AU) companion to the K0V exoplanet host star HD 3651A. We find a spectral type of T7.5+/-0.5, a temperature of 780-840 K, and a mass of 40-72 Mjup; its bolometric luminosity and effective temperature are among the lowest measured for any brown dwarf. We estimate an age of 3-12 Gyr for the primary star HD 3651A and find that it is ~3x older than the K4V star Gl 570A (1-5 Gyr), the host star of the T7.5 dwarf Gl 570D. HD 3651B belongs to the rare class of substellar objects that are companions to main-sequence stars and thus provides a new benchmark for studying very low-temperature objects. Given their similar temperatures (within ~30 K) and metallicities (within ~0.1 dex) but different ages, a comparison of HD 3651B and GL 570D allows us to examine gravity-sensitive diagnostics in ultracool spectra. We find that the expected signature of HD 3651B's higher surface gravity due to its older age, namely a suppressed K-band flux relative to GL 570D, is not seen. Instead, the K-band flux of HD 3651B is enhanced compared to GL 570D, indicative of a younger age. Thus, the relative ages derived from interpretation of T dwarf spectra and from stellar activity indicators appear to be in discord. One likely explanation is that the K-band fluxes are also very sensitive to metallicity differences. Metallicity variations may be as important as surface gravity variations in causing spectral differences among field late-T dwarfs