Could icy impacts reconcile Venus with Earth and Mars

The problem of volatile sources in the martian atomosphere was studied. It is suggested that a combination of an impact by an icy planetesimal (radius about 150 km) and solar wind implantation of neon could explain the noble gas abundances on Venus. Early solar wind would supply the right amount of neon with the correct Ne-20/Ne-22 as compared with lunar soils. However, observations of noble gases in a fresh comet are needed to test this hypothesis