Accounting and enabling greater accountability: The suppressed role of the accounting intellect

Draft: Please do not quoteThis paper extends the work of Weiss and Berney (2004), Clarke et al., (2003), Chambers (1980; 1999) and Schuetze, (2001) by developing the argument further that the current Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) are a fundamental obstacle to producing reliable corporate information. Specifically, it is argued that the accounting profession may continue to evade accountability for corporate financial statements unless it responds to the intellectual issues in accounting. The paper shows that significant opportunities arose in the past - in the early part of the 1900s (during the aftermath of the US Securities Market Collapse), the debates of normative versus positive accounting (1930s – 1970s) and the audit expectations gap (1970s – 1990s) and finally during the aftermath of recent corporate collapses - for bringing intellectual solutions to accounting and auditing problems. However, instead of fulfilling its key obligations by introducing constructive solutions to the debated issues, the profession has continued to defend its abilities to serve the public interest and has promoted the notion of independence (again) as a means of both silencing its critics and arresting possible misrepresentations of corporate financial statements. Yet the real challenge is an intellectual one and the paper questions the ability of the accounting profession to control the intellectual aspects of its subject matter. Consequently, critics of accounting are likely to construe this failure as a clear signal of the inability of the profession to maintain control over its discipline. Addressing this challenge therefore is of paramount importance for convincing critics that the profession is, in fact, able to self-regulate its affairs.UnpublishedAllen, K., ‘In pursuit of professional dominance: Australian Accounting 1953-1985’, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 4, No. 1, 1991. Boys, P., ‘The origins and evolution of the accountancy profession’. In W. Habgood (eds), Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. A guide to historical records (pp. 1-63), Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1994. Bazerman, M. H., G. Loewenstein and D. A. Moore, ‘Why good accountants do bad audits’, Harvard Business Review, November 2002. Chambers, R. J., ‘The case for simplicity in accounting’, ABACUS, Vol. 35, 1999. Chambers, R. J., ‘The myths and the science of accounting’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 5, No. 1, 1980. Chambers, R. J., Accounting Finance and Management, Arthur Anderson & Co, 1969. Chambers, R. J., ‘Price variation accounting – An Improved representation’. Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 5, Autumn 1967. Chambers, R. J., Accounting, Evaluation and Economic Behaviour, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall Inc, 1966. Chambers, R. J., ‘The price level problem and some intellectual grooves’, Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 3, Autumn 1965. Chandler, R., and J. R. Edwards, ‘Recurring Issues in Auditing: Back to the Future’, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 9, No. 2, 1996. Clarke, F., G. Dean and K. Oliver, Corporate Collapse: Accounting, Regulatory and Ethical Failure (2nd edn), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 2003. Clarke, F., G. Dean, and E. Houghton, ‘Revitalising group accounting: Improving accountability’, Australian Accounting Review, Vol. 12, No. 3, 2002. Coffee, J. C. Jr., Understanding Enron: “Its about the gatekeepers, stupid”, The Business Lawyer, Vol. 57, No. 4, 2002. Conrad, C., “The Illusion of reform: Corporate discourse and agenda denial in the 2002 “Corporate Meltdown”, Rhetoric & Public Affairs, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2004. Eden, Y., A. Ovadia, and A. Zuckerman, ‘Rethinking Sarbanes-Oxley’. CMA Management, May 2003. Eichenwald, K., ‘Pushing accounting rules to the Edge of the Envelope: Report focuses on Tyco’s aggressive tactics’, New York Times, December 2002. Elliott, R. K. and P. D. Jacobson, ‘SEC Independence Concepts’, The CPA Journal, Vol. 68, No. 4, 1998. Friedson, E., Professional Powers: A study of the Institutionalization of Formal Knowledge, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986. Hooks, K. L., ‘Professionalism and self interest: A critical view of the expectations gap’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 3, No. 2, 1992. Hopwood, A. G., ‘Ambiguity, knowledge and territorial claims: Some observations on the doctrine of substance over form: A review essay’, British Accounting Review, Vol. 22, 1990. Humphrey, C., P. Moizer, and S. Turley, The audit expectations gap in Britain: An empirical investigation, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 23, 1993. Humphrey, C., P. Moizer and S. Turley, “The audit expectations gap-plus ca change, plus c’est la meme chose? Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 3, No. 2, 1992. Landis, J. M., ‘Speech to the New York Society of Certified Public Accountants’. 1933. Leech, T., ‘Sarbanes_Oxley Act. Basel II vs. Sarbanes-Oxley : which wins?’, Global Risk Regulator, 2003. Levitt, A., ‘The “Numbers Game”’, Addressed delivered at the NYU Center for Law and Business, New York, September 1998. Levitt, A., ‘Renewing the covenant with investors’. Addressed delivered at the NYU Center for Law and Business, New York, May 2000. MacNeal, K., Truth in Accounting, Houston: Scholars Book Co, 1939. Markham-Lester, V., Victorian Insolvency. Bankruptcy, imprisonment for debt, and company winding-up in nineteenth-century England, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995. Matthewson, J. and N. Roland, ‘SEC’s Pitt calls for ‘Principles-Based’ Accounting’, Bloomberg News, February 2002. Napier, C. and C. Noke, ‘Accounting and law: an historical overview of an uneasy relationship’, In M. Bromwich and A. Hopwood (eds), Accounting and the law. Hemel Hempstead: Prentice Hall, 1992. O’Connor, S. M., “Be careful what you wish for: How accountants and Congress created the problem of auditor independence”, Boston College Law Review, Vol. 45, 2004. Power, M. K., ‘Auditing and the production of legitimacy’. Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 28, 2003. Reiter, S. A. and P. F. Williams, “The philosophy and rhetoric of auditor independence concepts”, Business Ethics Quarterly, Vol. 14, No. 3, 2004. Schuetze, W. P., ‘What are assets and liabilities? Where is true north? (Accounting that my sister would understand)’, ABACUS, Vol. 37, No. 1, 2001. Seligman, J., The Transformation of Wall Street: A History of the Securities and Exchange Commission and Modern Corporate Finance, Third Edition, Aspen Publishers, 2003. Sikka, P., A. Puxty, H. Willmott, and C. Cooper, Eliminating the Expectations Gap?, Chartered Association of Certified Accountants, 1992. Sikka, P. and H. Willmott, ‘The power of ‘independence’: Defending and extending the jurisdiction of accounting in the United Kingdom’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 20, No. 6, 1995. Simms, A. and J. Oram, Five Brothers. The rise and nemesis of the big bean counters, New Economics Foundation: London, United Kingdom, 2002. [Online] (Available, http://www.neweconomics.org). Shafer, W. E., A. A. Ketchand, and R. E. Morris, ‘Auditors willingness to advocate client-preferred accounting principles’ Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 52, 2004. Stacey, N. H. A., English Accountancy: a Study of Social and Economic History 1800-1954, London: Gee, 1954. Sterling, R., Toward a Science of Accounting, Houston: Scholars Book Co, 1979. Sterling, R., ‘Accounting Power’, in: G. J. Staubus (eds), Making Accounting Decisions. Houston: Scholars Book Co, 1977. Sterling, R., Theory of the Measurement of Enterprise Income, Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1970. Walker, S. P., ‘The genesis of professional organization in English accountancy’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 29, 2004. Walker, S. P., ‘Benign sacerdotalist or pious assailant. The rise of the professional accountant in British management’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 25, 2000. Weiss, M. I. and E. A. Berney, ‘Restoring investor trust in auditing standards and accounting principles’, Harvard Journal on Legislation, Vol. 41, 2004