We construct the most general parity-even higher-derivative N $$ \mathcal{N} $$ = 1 off-shell supergravity model in three dimensions with a maximum of six derivatives. Excluding terms quadratic in the curvature tensor with two explicit derivatives and requiring the absence of ghosts in a linearized approximation around an AdS 3 background, we find that there is a unique supersymmetric invariant which we call supersymmetric ‘cubic extended’ New Massive Gravity. The purely gravitational part of this invariant is in agreement with an earlier analysis based upon the holographic c-theorem and coincides with an expansion of Born-Infeld gravity to the required order