In today’s fast changing knowledge economy, organizations are forced to give priority to strategic human resource development to gain and maintain a competitive advantage (Guthridge et al., The McKinsey Quarterly 1:49–59, 2008). Therefore, tools such as Personal Development Plans (PDPs) are increasingly implemented. This assessment tool is used for various purposes, ranging from evaluative purposes to developmental purposes (Smith and Tillema, Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 45:183–202, 2001). Although the power of a PDP lies in stimulating learning and professional development of employees, it can be questioned if implementing PDP with evaluative purposes does not jeopardize its developmental power. In this study, we focus on ...