When can marine reserves improve fisheries management?

Marine reserves are a promising tool for fisheries management and conservation of biodiversity, but they are not a panacea for fisheries management problems. For fisheries that target highly mobile single species with little or no by-catch or habitat impact, marine reserves provide few benefits compared to conventional fishery management tools. For fisheries that are multi-species or on more sedentary stocks, or for which broader ecological impacts of fishing are an issue, marine reserves have some potential advantages. Their successful use requires a case-by-case understanding of the spatial structure of impacted fisheries, ecosystems and human communities. Marine reserves, together with other fishery management tools, can help achieve broad fishery and biodiversity objectives, but their use will require careful planning and evaluation. Mistakes will be made, and without planning, monitoring and evaluation, we will not learn what worked, what did not, and why. If marine reserves are implemented without case by case evaluation and appropriate monitoring programs, there is a risk of unfulfilled expectations, the creation of disincentives, and a loss of credibility of what potentially is a valuable management tool.Fil: Hilborn, Ray. The George Washington University; Estados UnidosFil: Stokes, Kevin. Seafood Industry Council; Nueva ZelandaFil: Maguire, Jean Jacques. Halieutikos; CanadáFil: Smith, Tony. Csiro National Collections And Marine Infrastructure; AustraliaFil: Botsford, Louis W.. University of California; Estados UnidosFil: Mangel, Marc. University of California; Estados UnidosFil: Orensanz, Jose Maria. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas. Centro Científico Tecnológico Conicet - Centro Nacional Patagónico; ArgentinaFil: Parma, Ana María. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas. Centro Científico Tecnológico Conicet - Centro Nacional Patagónico; ArgentinaFil: Rice, Jake. Science Advisory Secretariat; CanadáFil: Bell, Johann. World Fish Center; MalasiaFil: Cochrane, Kevern L.. United Nations. Foof and Agriculture Organization. Fisheries Department; ItaliaFil: Garcia, Serge. United Nations. Foof and Agriculture Organization. Fisheries Department; ItaliaFil: Hall, Stephen J.. Australian Institute of Marine Science; AustraliaFil: Kirkwood, G. P.. Imperial College London; Reino UnidoFil: Sainsbury, Keith. Csiro National Collections And Marine Infrastructure; AustraliaFil: Stefansson, Gunnar. Marine Research Institute; IslandiaFil: Walters, Carl. University of British Columbia; Canad