Varying confidence levels for CVaR risk measures and minimax limits

Conditional value at risk (CVaR) has been widely studied as a risk measure. In this paper we add to this work by focusing on the choice of confidence level and its impact on optimization problems with CVaR appearing in the objective and also the constraints. We start by considering a problem in which CVaR is minimized and investigate the way in which it approximates the minimax robust optimization problem as the confidence level is driven to one. We make use of a consistent tail condition which ensures that the CVaR of a random function will converge uniformly to its supremum as the confidence level increases, and establish an error bound for the CVaR optimal solution under second order growth conditions. The results are extended to a minimization problem with a constraint on the CVaR value which in the limit as the confidence level approaches one coincides with a problem having semi-infinite constraints. We study the sample average approximation scheme for the CVaR constraints and establish an exponential rate of convergence for the sample averaged optimal solution. We propose a procedure to explore the possibility of varying the confidence level to a lower value which can give an advantage when there is a need to find good solutions to CVaR-constrained problems out of sample. Our numerical results demonstrate that using the optimal solution to an adjusted problem with lower confidence level can lead to better overall performance