High-resolution Photo-excitation Measurements Exacerbate the Long-standing Fe XVII Emission Problem

We measured the L-shell soft X-ray fluorescence of Fe XVII ions in an electron beam ion trap following resonant photo-excitation using synchrotron radiation provided by the P04 beamline at PETRA III. Special attention is paid to two 2p-3d transitions, the 3C and 3D lines that are essential plasma diagnostics tools for astrophysics. Their resulting oscillator-strength ratio, f(3C)/f(3D) = 3.09(8)(6), is three times more accurate than previous results. The present ratio clearly departs by approximately 5-sigmas from the newest ab initio calculations but confirms previous laboratory measurements and astrophysical observations. A ten thousand-fold reduction in excitation-photon intensity and ten times higher spectral resolution allow us to exclude current explanations, reinstating a forty-year-old atomic-physics puzzle