P450-BM3-Catalyzed Sulfoxidation versus Hydroxylation: A Common or Two Different Catalytically Active Species?

While the mechanism of the P450-catalyzed oxidative hydroxylation of organic compounds has been studied in detail for many years, less is known about sulfoxidation. Depending upon the structure of the respective substrate, heme-Fe═O (Cpd I), heme–Fe(III)–OOH (Cpd 0), and heme–Fe(III)–H2O2 (protonated Cpd 0) have been proposed as reactive intermediates. In the present study, we consider the transformation of isosteric substrates via sulfoxidation and oxidative hydroxylation, respectively, catalyzed by regio- and enantioselective mutants of P450-BM3 which were constructed by directed evolution. 1-Thiochromanone and 1-tetralone were used as the isosteric substrates because, unlike previous studies involving fully flexible compounds such as thia-fatty acids and fatty acids, respectively, these compounds are rigid and cannot occur in a multitude of different conformations and binding modes in the large P450-BM3 binding pocket. The experimental results comprising activity and regio- and enantioselectivity, flanked by molecular dynamics computations within a time scale of 300 ns and QM/MM calculations of transition-state energies, unequivocally show that heme-Fe═O (Cpd I) is the common catalytically active intermediate in both sulfoxidation and oxidative hydroxylation