The Church’s One Foundation: the Use of Scripture in the Church in the Theologies of Robert Jenson, Kevin Vanhoozer, and Rowan Williams

Robert Jenson, Kevin Vanhoozer, and Rowan Williams represent three distinct conceptions of how scripture should be used in relation to the five sources of theology: scripture, church, tradition, reason, and experience. Jenson argues that the church, under the guidance of the Spirit, should ultimately determine scripture’s meaning. Vanhoozer contends that scripture should be regarded as highest in authority, not the interpretations of the church or tradition, nor reason or experience. Williams, finally, proposes that Christ, experienced apart from infallible mediators, should ultimately norm how scripture should be used. Reason provides the means, in light of historical testimony, to know Christ’s original significance, while the church and tradition function as further witnesses to Christ as the revelation of God. Evaluating these three positions, it is concluded that all three are consistent, but that Vanhoozer’s best takes into account the facts of history, and has fewer practical problems than Jenson’s position does.Master of Arts (MA