Mutualistic and antagonistic effects of plant-animal and plant-fungal interactions on plant recruitment at the tree line

Antagonistic and mutualistic species interactions provide important ecosystem functions affecting plant population dynamics and distribution. Many of these functions are important for the regeneration of plants, either by limiting or facilitating successful transition between life stages. Interactions can occur across the whole geographical range of a species and thereby encompass different environmental gradients, such as changes in temperature or water availability. Understanding the joint effects of species interactions and environmental factors on the regeneration of plants is key for understanding plant population dynamics under global change and could provide important recommendations for managing and conservation efforts. My thesis aimed at advancing the knowledge of how species interactions depend on environmental conditions and jointly affect plant recruitment along the elevational distribution of plants. This thesis includes three chapters in which I studied the effects of animal seed deposition, seed predation, mycorrhizal and pathogenic fungi occurrences as well as abiotic and biotic environmental factors on the recruitment of Swiss stone pine (Pinus cembra). I conducted fieldwork in the Swiss Alps across the entire elevational distribution of the pine (1850 – 2250 m a.s.l). Over a period of three years, I recorded animal seed deposition by spotted nutcrackers (Nucifraga caryocatactes) and conducted seed translocation experiments. Further, I assessed fungal communities using DNA metabarcoding. I measured abiotic environmental factors such as temperature, water and light availability, pH, as well as biotic environmental factors such as distance to conspecific adults and ground vegetation cover. In my thesis, I used a broad range of community ecology approaches, from seed dispersal ecology to experimental plant ecology and microbial ecology. First, I investigated the effects of environmental factors on four recruitment processes (i.e. seed deposition, seed predation, seed germination, seedling survival) of Swiss stone pine. Further, I aimed at identifying the most important recruitment processes potentially limiting pine regeneration across its elevational range. To investigate pine recruitment, I firstly tested how seed deposition, seed predation, seed germination and seedling survival were affected by the microhabitat characteristics ultimately determining where a seed arrives in the environment (i.e. canopy cover & ground vegetation cover). Secondly, I applied a sensitivity analysis to investigate which of the four recruitment processes poses limitation to the pines’ regeneration across its range. My results reveal that the importance of particular recruitment processes varies along the pines’ elevational range. I found that at the lower range margin and the distribution centre seed germination and seedling survival were the main limiting factors, whereas animal-mediated seed dispersal became especially important at the upper range margin. My study contributes to the field with a new approach for disentangling the relative importance of recruitment processes across environmental gradients and thereby could help to project how plant recruitment might respond to future changes in environmental conditions. The second aim of my study was to investigate how abiotic and biotic environmental factors affect the occurrence of Swiss stone pine-associated pathogenic and mutualistic fungi by combining field measurements of environmental factors with a DNA metabarcoding approach. I identified potentially important fungal interaction partners of the pine and determined drivers shaping their occurrences. My results reveal that generalist fungi were not affected by abiotic and biotic environmental factors. However, specialist pathogens showed patterns according to the Janzen-Connell framework (i.e. accumulation of pathogen close to adult plants). Interestingly, I found evidence for an “inverse” Janzen-Connell effect, i.e. high abundance of a specialist mutualist close to adult plants, potentially mitigating effects of soil pathogens close to parent trees. Further, I found that pine-associated fungi are distributed widely within and beyond the range of their host plant, adding knowledge on how mutualisms and antagonisms might be affected when plants move their distributional range upwards. Finally, I investigated how known and unknown plant-associated fungi affect the regeneration of Swiss stone pine in an environmental context. My results suggest that seedling establishment was most strongly affected by abiotic environmental factors, such as light availability and maximum summer temperature. Further, the results indicate that seedling survival was affected by biotic environmental factors, i.e. fungal agents, with high abundances of a known fungal pathogen co-occurring with low seedling survival rates. My results also reveal that known mycorrhizal partners as well as a large number of unknown fungal operational taxonomic units (OTUs) were associated with the survival of seedlings. My findings highlight the importance of plant-fungal interactions for plant recruitment and offer a feasible approach for the identification of hidden plant-fungal associations in highly complex DNA metabarcoding datasets. This approach offers a valuable tool for investigating plant-microbe interactions, ultimately helping to understand plant population dynamics. My dissertation adds to a deeper understanding on the linkage between plant regeneration and species interactions, especially on how plant-animal and plant-fungal interactions in concert with environmental factors shape plant recruitment. My study reveals the importance of animal-mediated seed dispersal and fungal pathogens in plant recruitment with consequences for potential range shifts of plant species. My thesis has important implications for conservation and management efforts by informing on key species interactions under environmental change