Issues in using commodity operating systems for time-dependent tasks: experiences from a study of windows NT

ManuscriptThis paper presents a snapshot of early results from a study of Windows NT aimed at understanding and improving its limitations when used for time-dependent tasks, such as those that arise for audio and video processing. Clearly there are time scales for which it can achieve effectively perfect reliability, such as the onesecond deadlines present in the Tiger Video Filesystem. Other time scales, such as reliable sub-millisecond scheduling of periodic tasks in user space, are clearly out of reach. Yet, there is an interesting middle ground between these time scales in which deadlines may be met, but will not always be. This study focuses on system and application behaviors in this region with the short-term goals of understanding and improving the real-time responsiveness of applications using Windows NT 5.0 and a longer-term goal of prototyping and recommending possible scheduling and resource management enhancements to future Microsoft systems products. Finally, while this paper primarily contains examples and results from Windows NT, we believe that the kinds of limitations and artifacts identified may also apply to other commodity systems such as the many UNIX variants. Indeed, this paper is primarily intended to provide a starting point for fruitful discussions along these lines at the workshop and not as a record of completed work