Psychological evidence suggests that people's learning behavior is often prone to a "myside bias" or "irrational belief persistence" in contrast to learning behavior exclusively based on objective data. In the context of Byesian learning such a bias may result in diverging posterior beliefs and attitude polarization even if agents receive identical information. Such patterns cannot be explained by the standard model of rational Bayesian learning that implies convergent beliefs. As our key contribution, we therefore develop formal models of Bayesian learning. We derive conditions under which beliefs may diverge in the learning process and thus conform wiht the psychological evidence. Key to our approach is the assuption of ambiguous beliefs ...