Hypothetical Datalog: Complexity and Expressibility

We present an extension of Horn-clause logic which can hypothetically add and delete tuples from a database. Such logics have been discussed in the literature, but their complexities and expressibilities have remained an open question. This paper examines two such logics in the function-free, predicate case. It is shown, in particular, that augmenting Horn-clause logic with hypothetical addition increases its data-complexity from PTIME to PSPACE. When deletions are added as well, complexity increases again, to EXPTIME. We then augment the logic with negation-as-failure and develop the notion of stratified hypothetical rulebases. It is shown that negation does not increase complexity. To establish expressibility, we view the logic as a query language for relational databases. It is shown that any typed generic query that is computable in PSPACE can be expressed as a stratified rulebase of hypothetical additions. Similarly, any typed generic query that is computable in EXPTIME can be exp..